CNR -- National Research Council of Italy, Collegio Carlo Alberto, Via Real Collegio, n. 30, 10024, Moncalieri (TO), Italy.
Environ Res. 2022 Oct;213:113566. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2022.113566. Epub 2022 May 31.
In the presence of pandemic threats, such as Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) crisis, vaccination is one of the fundamental strategies to cope with negative effects of new viral agents in society. The rollout of vast vaccination campaigns also generates the main issue of hesitancy and resistance to vaccines in a share of people. Many studies have investigated how to reduce the social resistance to vaccinations, however the maximum level of vaccinable people against COVID-19 (and in general against pandemic diseases), without coercion in countries, is unknown. The goal of this study is to solve the problem here by developing an empirical analysis, based on global data, to estimate the max share of people vaccinable in relation to socioeconomic wellbeing of nations. Results, based on 150 countries, reveal that vaccinations increase with the income per capita, achieving the maximum share of about 70% of total population, without coercion. This information can provide new knowledge to establish the appropriate goal of vaccination campaigns and in general of health policies to cope with next pandemic impacts, without restrictions that create socioeconomic problems. Overall, then, nations have a natural level of max vaccinable people (70% of population), but strict policies and mandates to achieve 90% of vaccinated population can reduce the quality of democracy and generate socioeconomic issues higher than (pandemic) crisis.
在面临大流行病威胁时,如 2019 年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)危机,接种疫苗是应对社会中新病毒制剂负面影响的基本策略之一。大规模疫苗接种运动的开展也在一定程度上产生了人们对接种疫苗的犹豫和抵制。许多研究调查了如何减少对疫苗接种的社会抵制,但在没有强制的情况下,各国最大限度地可接种 COVID-19(一般而言,针对大流行疾病)疫苗的人数是未知的。本研究的目标是通过开发基于全球数据的实证分析来解决这一问题,以估计与国家社会经济福祉相关的可接种疫苗人群的最大比例。基于 150 个国家的数据结果表明,疫苗接种率随着人均收入的增加而增加,在没有强制的情况下,可达到约总人口 70%的最高接种比例。这些信息可以为制定适当的疫苗接种运动目标提供新的知识,一般而言,还可以为应对下一次大流行影响的卫生政策提供新的知识,而不会产生造成社会经济问题的限制。总体而言,各国都有一定比例的最高可接种人群(占总人口的 70%),但为实现 90%的接种人口而采取严格的政策和强制手段可能会降低民主的质量,并产生比(大流行病)危机更高的社会经济问题。