Venegas-Carro Maria, Kramer Andreas, Moreno-Villanueva Maria, Gruber Markus
Human Performance Research Centre, Department of Sport Science, University of Konstanz, 78464 Konstanz, Germany.
Sports (Basel). 2022 Nov 2;10(11):171. doi: 10.3390/sports10110171.
This study evaluated the reliability and sensitivity of a set of different common strength and power tests in a healthy adult population in a span of 9 weeks. Seventeen subjects (24.2 ± 2.2 years, 1.75 ± 0.10 m, 68.6 ± 14.2 kg, seven women) participated in the study. We tested countermovement jumps, reactive hops, and the maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) of handgrip and isometric knee extension. The tests were conducted in three separate sessions across a nine-week period, with one week between the first two sessions and eight weeks between the second and the third. Reliability and sensitivity statistics for each test were calculated for both the average of three trials and the best result during each session. The MVC of isometric knee extension and handgrip, as well as the countermovement jump test, demonstrated very high reliability and sensitivity over the nine-week period. The peak force of the reactive hops demonstrated high reliability but high sensitivity only for the average but not for the best result. The average contact time of reactive hops was neither a sensitive nor reliable measurement. In conclusion, isometric maximal knee extension and handgrip tests, as well as countermovement jumps and peak force of reactive hops, can be used as reliable and sensitive measurements of isometric and reactive strength and power over time periods of up to eight weeks. We recommend the use of the average results of three trials instead of the best performance value for longitudinal studies, as this procedure produces more consistent results and a lower measurement error.
本研究评估了一组不同的常见力量和功率测试在9周内对健康成年人群的可靠性和敏感性。17名受试者(年龄24.2±2.2岁,身高1.75±0.10米,体重68.6±14.2千克,7名女性)参与了该研究。我们测试了反向纵跳、反应性单脚跳以及握力和等长膝关节伸展的最大自主收缩(MVC)。测试在9周内分三个单独的阶段进行,前两个阶段之间间隔1周,第二个和第三个阶段之间间隔8周。针对每个测试的三次试验平均值和每个阶段的最佳结果计算了可靠性和敏感性统计数据。等长膝关节伸展和握力的MVC以及反向纵跳测试在9周期间表现出非常高的可靠性和敏感性。反应性单脚跳的峰值力表现出高可靠性,但仅对平均值具有高敏感性,对最佳结果则不然。反应性单脚跳的平均接触时间既不是一个敏感的测量指标也不可靠。总之,等长最大膝关节伸展和握力测试,以及反向纵跳和反应性单脚跳的峰值力,可作为长达8周时间段内等长和反应性力量及功率的可靠且敏感的测量指标。我们建议在纵向研究中使用三次试验的平均结果而非最佳表现值,因为此方法能产生更一致的结果且测量误差更低。