Sage Bionetworks, Seattle, Washington, United States of America.
Department of Psychiatry, University of Oxford, Oxford, Oxfordshire, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2023 Apr 19;18(4):e0279857. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0279857. eCollection 2023.
Mobile devices offer a scalable opportunity to collect longitudinal data that facilitate advances in mental health treatment to address the burden of mental health conditions in young people. Sharing these data with the research community is critical to gaining maximal value from rich data of this nature. However, the highly personal nature of the data necessitates understanding the conditions under which young people are willing to share them. To answer this question, we developed the MindKind Study, a multinational, mixed methods study that solicits young people's preferences for how their data are governed and quantifies potential participants' willingness to join under different conditions. We employed a community-based participatory approach, involving young people as stakeholders and co-researchers. At sites in India, South Africa, and the UK, we enrolled 3575 participants ages 16-24 in the mobile app-mediated quantitative study and 143 participants in the public deliberation-based qualitative study. We found that while youth participants have strong preferences for data governance, these preferences did not translate into (un)willingness to join the smartphone-based study. Participants grappled with the risks and benefits of participation as well as their desire that the "right people" access their data. Throughout the study, we recognized young people's commitment to finding solutions and co-producing research architectures to allow for more open sharing of mental health data to accelerate and derive maximal benefit from research.
移动设备提供了一个可扩展的机会,可以收集纵向数据,从而推动精神健康治疗的进步,以解决年轻人精神健康状况的负担。与研究界共享这些数据对于从这类丰富数据中获得最大价值至关重要。然而,数据的高度个人化性质要求了解年轻人愿意分享数据的条件。为了回答这个问题,我们开发了 MindKind 研究,这是一项多国家、混合方法的研究,征求年轻人对其数据治理方式的偏好,并量化潜在参与者在不同条件下加入的意愿。我们采用了基于社区的参与式方法,让年轻人作为利益相关者和共同研究者参与其中。在印度、南非和英国的研究点,我们招募了 3575 名年龄在 16 至 24 岁的参与者参加基于移动应用的定量研究,以及 143 名参与者参加基于公众讨论的定性研究。我们发现,尽管青年参与者对数据治理有强烈的偏好,但这些偏好并没有转化为(不)愿意参加基于智能手机的研究。参与者在参与的风险和收益以及他们希望“合适的人”访问他们的数据方面存在纠结。在整个研究过程中,我们认识到年轻人致力于寻找解决方案,并共同制定研究架构,以允许更开放地共享精神健康数据,从而加速并从研究中获得最大利益。