Katsushika Susumu, Kodera Satoshi, Sawano Shinnosuke, Shinohara Hiroki, Setoguchi Naoto, Tanabe Kengo, Higashikuni Yasutomi, Takeda Norifumi, Fujiu Katsuhito, Daimon Masao, Akazawa Hiroshi, Morita Hiroyuki, Komuro Issei
Department of Cardiovascular Medicine, The University of Tokyo Hospital, 7-3-1 Hongo, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113-8655, Japan.
Department of Cardiovascular Medicine, Mitsui Memorial Hospital, 1 Kanda-Izumi-cho, Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo 101-8643, Japan.
Eur Heart J Digit Health. 2023 Apr 17;4(3):254-264. doi: 10.1093/ehjdh/ztad027. eCollection 2023 May.
The black box nature of artificial intelligence (AI) hinders the development of interpretable AI models that are applicable in clinical practice. We aimed to develop an AI model for classifying patients of reduced left ventricular ejection fraction (LVEF) from 12-lead electrocardiograms (ECG) with the decision-interpretability.
We acquired paired ECG and echocardiography datasets from the central and co-operative institutions. For the central institution dataset, a random forest model was trained to identify patients with reduced LVEF among 29 907 ECGs. Shapley additive explanations were applied to 7196 ECGs. To extract the model's decision criteria, the calculated Shapley additive explanations values were clustered for 192 non-paced rhythm patients in which reduced LVEF was predicted. Although the extracted criteria were different for each cluster, these criteria generally comprised a combination of six ECG findings: negative T-wave inversion in I/V5-6 leads, low voltage in I/II/V4-6 leads, Q wave in V3-6 leads, ventricular activation time prolongation in I/V5-6 leads, S-wave prolongation in V2-3 leads, and corrected QT interval prolongation. Similarly, for the co-operative institution dataset, the extracted criteria comprised a combination of the same six ECG findings. Furthermore, the accuracy of seven cardiologists' ECG readings improved significantly after watching a video explaining the interpretation of these criteria (before, 62.9% ± 3.9% vs. after, 73.9% ± 2.4%; = 0.02).
We visually interpreted the model's decision criteria to evaluate its validity, thereby developing a model that provided the decision-interpretability required for clinical application.
人工智能(AI)的黑箱性质阻碍了适用于临床实践的可解释AI模型的开发。我们旨在开发一种AI模型,用于根据12导联心电图(ECG)对左心室射血分数(LVEF)降低的患者进行分类,并具有决策可解释性。
我们从中心机构和合作机构获取了配对的ECG和超声心动图数据集。对于中心机构数据集,训练了一个随机森林模型,以在29907份ECG中识别LVEF降低的患者。将Shapley附加解释应用于7196份ECG。为了提取模型的决策标准,对预测LVEF降低的192例非起搏心律患者的计算出的Shapley附加解释值进行聚类。尽管每个聚类提取的标准不同,但这些标准通常包括六个ECG表现的组合:I/V5-6导联T波倒置阴性、I/II/V4-6导联低电压、V