Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore.
Lloyd's Register Foundation Institute for the Public Understanding of Risk, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore.
J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci. 2023 Nov 14;78(11):1870-1878. doi: 10.1093/geronb/gbad113.
Discussions on the political scene in the United States have been accompanied by the notion that the country has morphed into a gerontocracy, a system of governance where power is wielded predominantly by older individuals. With rising life expectancy, more as well as older candidates are likely to run for and stay in office. This study analyzes perceptions regarding the older political leadership of the United States.
We collected 3,599 tweets containing the word "gerontocracy" which were uploaded between September 10, 2022 and November 10, 2022, a month prior to the midterm elections in the United States, when this topic was likely to have sparked considerable discussion. After applying our exclusion criteria, 1,266 tweets were retained. Our qualitative content analysis was performed inductively and deductively.
Seven themes emerged. Most tweets (24%; N = 304) highlighted that "Gerontocracy is a Problem" (Theme 1). Theme 2 (21%) focused on how "Democracy is a Sham" (N = 270). Theme 3 (19%) positioned "Old Age as the Problem and Youth as the Solution" (N = 234). Theme 4 (11%) was about how "The Future is at Stake" (N = 145). "Health Concerns" dominated Theme 5 (10%; N = 126). Theme 6 looked at "Structural Reforms" (9%, N = 115). Theme 7 "In Defense of the Gerontocracy" formed 6% of the data set (N = 72).
Attitudes toward older politicians are commonly tied to negative stereotypes surrounding old age. As the population ages, it is paramount that society focuses on potentially more important considerations in the evaluation of the actual caliber of a politician.
在美国的政治舞台上,人们一直在讨论这样一种观点,即美国已经变成了一个老人统治的国家,即权力主要由老年人掌握的治理体系。随着预期寿命的提高,更多的老年人以及更年轻的候选人可能会参选并继续留任。本研究分析了人们对美国老年政治领导层的看法。
我们收集了 3599 条包含“老人统治”一词的推文,这些推文是在 2022 年 9 月 10 日至 11 月 10 日之间上传的,这是在美国中期选举前的一个月,当时这个话题可能引发了相当多的讨论。在应用排除标准后,保留了 1266 条推文。我们的定性内容分析采用了归纳和演绎的方法。
出现了七个主题。大多数推文(24%;N=304)强调“老人统治是一个问题”(主题 1)。主题 2(21%)关注的是“民主是一种骗局”(N=270)。主题 3(19%)将“老年作为问题,青年作为解决方案”(N=234)置于首位。主题 4(11%)是关于“未来岌岌可危”(N=145)。“健康问题”主导了主题 5(10%;N=126)。主题 6 探讨了“结构性改革”(9%,N=115)。主题 7“为老人统治辩护”占数据集的 6%(N=72)。
对老年政治家的态度通常与围绕老年的负面刻板印象有关。随着人口老龄化,社会必须将重点放在评估政治家实际能力时可能更重要的考虑因素上。