Sazili Awis Qurni, Kumar Pavan, Hayat Muhammad Nizam
Halal Products Research Institute, Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM), Putra Infoport, Serdang 43400, Malaysia.
Department of Animal Science, Faculty of Agriculture, Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM), Serdang 43400, Malaysia.
Animals (Basel). 2023 Sep 29;13(19):3061. doi: 10.3390/ani13193061.
Muslim scholars are not unanimous on the issue of the application of stunning in the halal slaughtering of animals. Appropriate stunning makes animals unconscious instantaneously, thus avoiding unnecessary pain and stress during the slaughtering of animals. The present review comprehensively summarizes the available scientific literature on stunning methods in view of their halal compliance during the slaughter of animals. The issue of maximum blood loss, reversibility of consciousness, and animals remaining alive during the halal cut are the key determinants of approval of stunning in the halal slaughter. Further, missed stuns due to poor maintenance of equipment, improper applications, and poor restraining necessitates additional stunning attempts, which further aggravates pain and stress in animals. Scientific findings suggest that halal-compliant stunning technologies are reversible, do not kill animals prior to the halal cut, and do not obstruct blood loss. There is a need to carry out further research on the refinement of available stunning technologies and their application, proper restraints, proper identification of the death status of animals, and assurance of animal welfare in commercial halal meat production.
穆斯林学者在动物清真屠宰中使用致昏方法这一问题上并未达成一致。适当的致昏能使动物瞬间失去意识,从而避免在动物屠宰过程中产生不必要的疼痛和应激。本综述鉴于致昏方法在动物屠宰过程中的清真合规性,全面总结了现有的相关科学文献。最大失血量、意识可逆性以及在清真屠宰切口时动物仍存活的问题是清真屠宰中致昏方法能否被认可的关键决定因素。此外,由于设备维护不善、应用不当和约束不佳导致致昏失败,就需要进行额外的致昏尝试,这会进一步加剧动物的疼痛和应激。科学研究结果表明,符合清真要求的致昏技术是可逆的,在清真屠宰切口之前不会杀死动物,也不会阻碍失血。有必要对现有致昏技术的改进及其应用、适当的约束、动物死亡状态的正确识别以及商业清真肉类生产中的动物福利保障进行进一步研究。