Kleinitz Pauline, Sabariego Carla, Llewellyn Gwynnyth, Taloafiri Elsie, Mangar Ariane, Baskota Rabindra, Marahatta Kedar, Maduwage Shiromi, Khin Myo Hla, Wonanji Vivian, Sampa George, Al-Rjoub Ali, Al-Daod Jaber, Cieza Alarcos
Sensory Functions, Disability and Rehabilitation Unit, Department for Noncommunicable Diseases, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Faculty of Health Sciences and Medicine, University of Lucerne, Lucerne, Switzerland.
PLoS One. 2024 Feb 5;19(2):e0297109. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0297109. eCollection 2024.
The need for rehabilitation is growing due to health and demographic trends, especially the rise of non-communicable diseases and the rapid ageing of the global population. However, the extent to which rehabilitation is integrated into health systems is mostly unclear. Our objective is to describe and compare the nature and extent of integration of rehabilitation within health systems across nine middle-income countries using available Systematic Assessment of Rehabilitation Situation (STARS) reports.
Cross-country comparative study with variable-oriented design using available rehabilitation health system assessment reports from nine middle income countries.
The integration of rehabilitation into health systems is limited across countries. Governance and financing for rehabilitation are mostly established within health ministries but weakly so, while health information systems are characterized by no available data or data that is insufficient or not routinely generated. The overall numbers of rehabilitation workforce per capita are low, with frequent reports of workforce challenges. In most countries the availability of longer-stay, high-intensity rehabilitation is extremely low, the availability of rehabilitation in tertiary hospitals is modest and in government supported primary care its almost non-existent. Multiple concerns about rehabilitation quality arose but the lack of empirical data hinders formal appraisal.
The study sheds light on the limited integration of rehabilitation in health systems and common areas of difficulty and challenge across nine middle income countries. All countries were found to have a basis on which to strengthen rehabilitation and there were often multiple areas within each health system building block that required action in order to improve the situation. Findings can inform governments, regional and global agencies to support future efforts to strengthen rehabilitation. Additionally, our study demonstrates the value of STARS reports for health policy and systems research and can serve as a model for further comparative studies.
由于健康和人口趋势,尤其是非传染性疾病的增加以及全球人口的快速老龄化,康复需求不断增长。然而,康复在卫生系统中的整合程度大多尚不清楚。我们的目标是利用现有的康复状况系统评估(STARS)报告,描述和比较九个中等收入国家卫生系统中康复整合的性质和程度。
采用面向变量设计的跨国比较研究,使用九个中等收入国家现有的康复卫生系统评估报告。
各国康复在卫生系统中的整合程度有限。康复的治理和融资大多在卫生部内部建立,但力度较弱,而卫生信息系统的特点是没有可用数据或数据不足或不是常规生成的。人均康复劳动力总数较低,经常有劳动力挑战的报告。在大多数国家,长期、高强度康复服务的可及性极低,三级医院的康复服务可及性一般,而政府支持的初级保健中的康复服务几乎不存在。出现了对康复质量的多重担忧,但缺乏实证数据阻碍了正式评估。
该研究揭示了九个中等收入国家康复在卫生系统中的整合有限以及常见的困难和挑战领域。发现所有国家都有加强康复的基础,每个卫生系统组成部分内往往有多个领域需要采取行动以改善状况。研究结果可为政府、区域和全球机构提供信息,以支持未来加强康复的努力。此外,我们的研究证明了STARS报告在卫生政策和系统研究中的价值,并可作为进一步比较研究的模型。