Health Ethics and Policy Lab, ETH Zurich, Hottingerstrasse 10, 8092 Zurich, Switzerland.
Kintampo Health Research Centre, Research and Development Division, Ghana Health Service, Ghana.
Health Promot Int. 2024 Apr 1;39(2). doi: 10.1093/heapro/daae030.
Although digital health promotion (DHP) technologies for young people are increasingly available in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), there has been insufficient research investigating whether existing ethical and policy frameworks are adequate to address the challenges and promote the technological opportunities in these settings. In an effort to fill this gap and as part of a larger research project, in November 2022, we conducted a workshop in Cape Town, South Africa, entitled 'Unlocking the Potential of Digital Health Promotion for Young People in Low- and Middle-Income Countries'. The workshop brought together 25 experts from the areas of digital health ethics, youth health and engagement, health policy and promotion and technology development, predominantly from sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), to explore their views on the ethics and governance and potential policy pathways of DHP for young people in LMICs. Using the World Café method, participants contributed their views on (i) the advantages and barriers associated with DHP for youth in LMICs, (ii) the availability and relevance of ethical and regulatory frameworks for DHP and (iii) the translation of ethical principles into policies and implementation practices required by these policies, within the context of SSA. Our thematic analysis of the ensuing discussion revealed a willingness to foster such technologies if they prove safe, do not exacerbate inequalities, put youth at the center and are subject to appropriate oversight. In addition, our work has led to the potential translation of fundamental ethical principles into the form of a policy roadmap for ethically aligned DHP for youth in SSA.
虽然数字健康促进 (DHP) 技术在中低收入国家 (LMICs) 中越来越普及,但对于现有伦理和政策框架是否足以应对这些环境中的挑战并促进技术机会,研究还不够充分。为了填补这一空白,作为一个更大的研究项目的一部分,我们于 2022 年 11 月在南非开普敦举办了一次题为“挖掘数字健康促进在中低收入国家年轻人中的潜力”的研讨会。该研讨会汇集了来自数字健康伦理、青年健康和参与、健康政策和促进以及技术开发领域的 25 名专家,他们主要来自撒哈拉以南非洲 (SSA),探讨他们对 DHP 的伦理和治理以及潜在政策途径的看法在 LMICs 中的年轻人。使用世界咖啡屋方法,参与者就以下方面发表了看法:(i) DHP 对 LMIC 青年的优势和障碍,(ii) DHP 的伦理和监管框架的可用性和相关性,以及 (iii) 将伦理原则转化为这些政策所需的政策和实施实践,在 SSA 的背景下。我们对随后讨论的主题分析表明,如果这些技术被证明是安全的、不会加剧不平等、将青年置于中心位置并受到适当监督,就愿意促进这些技术。此外,我们的工作导致将基本伦理原则转化为 SSA 青年符合道德的 DHP 政策路线图的可能性。