Machine Learning Lab, Department of Medical Physics and Acoustics, School of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Oldenburg, Oldenburg, Germany.
PLoS Comput Biol. 2024 Jun 10;20(6):e1012192. doi: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1012192. eCollection 2024 Jun.
Conventional and electron microscopy visualize structures in the micrometer to nanometer range, and such visualizations contribute decisively to our understanding of biological processes. Due to different factors in recording processes, microscopy images are subject to noise. Especially at their respective resolution limits, a high degree of noise can negatively effect both image interpretation by experts and further automated processing. However, the deteriorating effects of strong noise can be alleviated to a large extend by image enhancement algorithms. Because of the inherent high noise, a requirement for such algorithms is their applicability directly to noisy images or, in the extreme case, to just a single noisy image without a priori noise level information (referred to as blind zero-shot setting). This work investigates blind zero-shot algorithms for microscopy image denoising. The strategies for denoising applied by the investigated approaches include: filtering methods, recent feed-forward neural networks which were amended to be trainable on noisy images, and recent probabilistic generative models. As datasets we consider transmission electron microscopy images including images of SARS-CoV-2 viruses and fluorescence microscopy images. A natural goal of denoising algorithms is to simultaneously reduce noise while preserving the original image features, e.g., the sharpness of structures. However, in practice, a tradeoff between both aspects often has to be found. Our performance evaluations, therefore, focus not only on noise removal but set noise removal in relation to a metric which is instructive about sharpness. For all considered approaches, we numerically investigate their performance, report their denoising/sharpness tradeoff on different images, and discuss future developments. We observe that, depending on the data, the different algorithms can provide significant advantages or disadvantages in terms of their noise removal vs. sharpness preservation capabilities, which may be very relevant for different virological applications, e.g., virological analysis or image segmentation.
传统和电子显微镜可以观察到微米到纳米范围内的结构,这些观察结果对我们理解生物过程有决定性的贡献。由于记录过程中的不同因素,显微镜图像会受到噪声的影响。特别是在各自的分辨率极限处,高度的噪声会对专家的图像解释和进一步的自动化处理产生负面影响。然而,通过图像增强算法可以在很大程度上减轻强烈噪声的恶化影响。由于固有噪声较高,这些算法的一个要求是可以直接应用于噪声图像,或者在极端情况下,仅应用于没有先验噪声水平信息的单个噪声图像(称为盲零拍设置)。这项工作研究了用于显微镜图像去噪的盲零拍算法。所研究方法应用的去噪策略包括:滤波方法、最近的前馈神经网络,这些网络被修改为可以在噪声图像上进行训练,以及最近的概率生成模型。作为数据集,我们考虑了透射电子显微镜图像,包括 SARS-CoV-2 病毒的图像和荧光显微镜图像。去噪算法的一个自然目标是在同时降低噪声的同时保留原始图像特征,例如结构的清晰度。然而,在实践中,通常必须在这两个方面之间找到折衷。因此,我们的性能评估不仅关注噪声去除,还将噪声去除与关于清晰度的有指导意义的指标相关联。对于所有考虑的方法,我们都在数值上研究了它们的性能,报告了它们在不同图像上的去噪/清晰度折衷,并讨论了未来的发展。我们观察到,根据数据的不同,不同的算法在噪声去除与清晰度保持能力方面可能具有显著的优势或劣势,这对于不同的病毒学应用可能非常重要,例如病毒学分析或图像分割。