Department of Radiology and Health Research Center, Baqiyatallah University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Baqiyatallah University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.
BMC Musculoskelet Disord. 2024 Jul 16;25(1):547. doi: 10.1186/s12891-024-07669-7.
This study aimed to evaluate a new deep-learning model for diagnosing avascular necrosis of the femoral head (AVNFH) by analyzing pelvic anteroposterior digital radiography.
The study sample included 1167 hips. The radiographs were independently classified into 6 stages by a radiologist using their simultaneous MRIs. After that, the radiographs were given to train and test the deep learning models of the project including SVM and ANFIS layer using the Python programming language and TensorFlow library. In the last step, the test set of hip radiographs was provided to two independent radiologists with different work experiences to compare their diagnosis performance to the deep learning models' performance using the F1 score and Mcnemar test analysis.
The performance of SVM for AVNFH detection (AUC = 82.88%) was slightly higher than less experienced radiologists (79.68%) and slightly lower than experienced radiologists (88.4%) without reaching significance (p-value > 0.05). Evaluation of the performance of SVM for pre-collapse AVNFH detection with an AUC of 73.58% showed significantly higher performance than less experienced radiologists (AUC = 60.70%, p-value < 0.001). On the other hand, no significant difference is noted between experienced radiologists and SVM for pre-collapse detection. ANFIS algorithm for AVNFH detection with an AUC of 86.60% showed significantly higher performance than less experienced radiologists (AUC = 79.68%, p-value = 0.04). Although reaching less performance compared to experienced radiologists statistically not significant (AUC = 88.40%, p-value = 0.20).
Our study has shed light on the remarkable capabilities of SVM and ANFIS as diagnostic tools for AVNFH detection in radiography. Their ability to achieve high accuracy with remarkable efficiency makes them promising candidates for early detection and intervention, ultimately contributing to improved patient outcomes.
本研究旨在通过分析骨盆前后位数字 X 线摄影来评估一种新的深度学习模型,用于诊断股骨头坏死(AVNFH)。
研究样本包括 1167 髋。放射科医生使用同时进行的 MRI 将 X 线片独立分为 6 期。之后,使用 Python 编程语言和 TensorFlow 库将 X 线片提供给项目的 SVM 和 ANFIS 层的深度学习模型进行训练和测试。最后,将一组髋部 X 线片的测试集提供给两位具有不同工作经验的独立放射科医生,使用 F1 评分和 McNemar 检验分析,比较他们的诊断性能与深度学习模型的性能。
SVM 对 AVNFH 检测的性能(AUC=82.88%)略高于经验较少的放射科医生(79.68%),略低于经验丰富的放射科医生(88.4%),但无显著差异(p 值>0.05)。SVM 对塌陷前 AVNFH 检测的 AUC 为 73.58%,其性能评估显示显著高于经验较少的放射科医生(AUC=60.70%,p 值<0.001)。另一方面,在塌陷前检测方面,经验丰富的放射科医生与 SVM 之间没有明显差异。用于 AVNFH 检测的 ANFIS 算法,其 AUC 为 86.60%,表现明显优于经验较少的放射科医生(AUC=79.68%,p 值=0.04)。尽管与经验丰富的放射科医生相比,统计上的性能略低,但无显著差异(AUC=88.40%,p 值=0.20)。
本研究揭示了 SVM 和 ANFIS 在 X 线摄影中用于 AVNFH 检测的出色诊断工具的能力。它们具有高效且高精度的能力,使其成为早期检测和干预的有前途的候选者,最终有助于改善患者的预后。