The University of Manchester, Centre for Primary Care & Health Services Research, Manchester, UK.
Donal O'Donoghue Renal Research Centre, Northern Care Alliance NHS Foundation Trust, Manchester, UK.
BMC Med. 2024 Aug 15;22(1):331. doi: 10.1186/s12916-024-03555-0.
Chronic kidney disease (CKD) is a global public health problem with major human and economic consequences. Despite advances in clinical guidelines, classification systems and evidence-based treatments, CKD remains underdiagnosed and undertreated and is predicted to be the fifth leading cause of death globally by 2040. This review aims to identify barriers and enablers to the effective detection, diagnosis, disclosure and management of CKD since the introduction of the Kidney Disease Outcomes Quality Initiative (KDOQI) classification in 2002, advocating for a renewed approach in response to updated Kidney Disease: Improving Global Outcomes (KDIGO) 2024 clinical guidelines. The last two decades of improvements in CKD care in the UK are underpinned by international adoption of the KDIGO classification system, mixed adoption of evidence-based treatments and research informed clinical guidelines and policy. Interpretation of evidence within clinical and academic communities has stimulated significant debate of how best to implement such evidence which has frequently fuelled and frustratingly forestalled progress in CKD care. Key enablers of effective CKD care include clinical classification systems (KDIGO), evidence-based treatments, electronic health record tools, financially incentivised care, medical education and policy changes. Barriers to effective CKD care are extensive; key barriers include clinician concerns regarding overdiagnosis, a lack of financially incentivised care in primary care, complex clinical guidelines, managing CKD in the context of multimorbidity, bureaucratic burden in primary care, underutilisation of sodium-glucose co-transporter-2 inhibitor (SGLT2i) medications, insufficient medical education in CKD, and most recently - a sustained disruption to routine CKD care during and after the COVID-19 pandemic. Future CKD care in UK primary care must be informed by lessons of the last two decades. Making step change, over incremental improvements in CKD care at scale requires a renewed approach that addresses key barriers to detection, diagnosis, disclosure and management across traditional boundaries of healthcare, social care, and public health. Improved coding accuracy in primary care, increased use of SGLT2i medications, and risk-based care offer promising, cost-effective avenues to improve patient and population-level kidney health. Financial incentives generally improve achievement of care quality indicators - a review of financial and non-financial incentives in CKD care is urgently needed.
慢性肾脏病(CKD)是一个全球性的公共卫生问题,给人类健康和经济带来了巨大的影响。尽管临床指南、分类系统和循证治疗都取得了进展,但 CKD 的诊断率仍然较低,治疗不足,预计到 2040 年,它将成为全球第五大死亡原因。本综述旨在确定自 2002 年肾脏病预后质量倡议(KDOQI)分类引入以来,有效检测、诊断、披露和管理 CKD 的障碍和促进因素,倡导针对更新的 2024 年肾脏病:改善全球结果(KDIGO)临床指南采取新的方法。英国在过去二十年中 CKD 护理的改善,是基于国际上采用 KDIGO 分类系统、采用循证治疗和以研究为基础的临床指南和政策相结合的结果。临床和学术界对证据的解读引发了激烈的争论,即如何最好地实施这些证据,这经常推动并令人沮丧地阻碍了 CKD 护理的进展。有效的 CKD 护理的关键促进因素包括临床分类系统(KDIGO)、循证治疗、电子健康记录工具、经济激励的护理、医学教育和政策变化。有效的 CKD 护理的障碍很多,主要障碍包括临床医生对过度诊断的担忧、初级保健中缺乏经济激励的护理、复杂的临床指南、在多种疾病共存的情况下管理 CKD、初级保健中的官僚负担、钠-葡萄糖共转运蛋白-2 抑制剂(SGLT2i)药物的利用不足、CKD 医学教育不足,以及最近在 COVID-19 大流行期间和之后对常规 CKD 护理的持续干扰。英国初级保健中未来的 CKD 护理必须吸取过去二十年的经验教训。要想在规模上实现 CKD 护理的重大转变,而不是渐进式的改善,就需要采取一种新的方法,跨越医疗保健、社会关怀和公共卫生的传统界限,解决检测、诊断、披露和管理方面的关键障碍。在初级保健中提高编码准确性、增加 SGLT2i 药物的使用以及基于风险的护理,为改善患者和人群的肾脏健康提供了有前途的、具有成本效益的途径。经济激励通常可以提高护理质量指标的实现,迫切需要对 CKD 护理的经济和非经济激励进行审查。