Department of Agronomy, Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN, USA.
Department of Agronomy and Plant Genetics, University of Minnesota, Northwest Research and Outreach Center, Crookston, MN, USA.
Heredity (Edinb). 2024 Dec;133(6):371-380. doi: 10.1038/s41437-024-00721-1. Epub 2024 Sep 5.
The year 2020 was a landmark year for wheat. The wheat HB4 event harboring a drought-resistant gene from sunflowers, received regulatory approval and was grown commercially in Argentina, with approval for food and feed in other countries. This, indeed, is many years after the adoption of genetic modifications in other crops. The lack of consumer acceptance and resulting trade barriers halted the commercialization of the earliest events and had a chilling effect on, especially, private Research & Development (R&D) investments. As regulations for modern breeding technologies such as genome-edited cultivars are being discussed and/or adopted across the globe, we would like to propose a framework to ensure that wheat is not left behind a second time as the potential benefits far outweigh the perceived risks. In this paper, after a review of the technical challenges wheat faces with the generation of trans- and cis-genic wheat varieties, we discuss some of the factors that could help demystify the risk/reward equation and thereby the consumer's reluctance or acceptance of these techniques for future wheat improvement. The advent of next-generation sequencing is shedding light on natural gene transfer between species and the number of perturbations other accepted techniques like mutagenesis create. The transition from classic breeding techniques and embracing transgenic, cisgenic, and genome editing approaches feels inevitable for wheat improvement if we are to develop climate-resilient wheat varieties to feed a growing world population.
2020 年是小麦具有里程碑意义的一年。含有向日葵抗旱基因的小麦 HB4 事件获得了监管部门的批准,并在阿根廷商业化种植,其他国家也批准其用于食品和饲料。这确实是在其他作物采用基因改造多年之后的事情了。由于缺乏消费者的认可和由此产生的贸易壁垒,最早的事件的商业化进程被停止,这对特别是私营部门的研究与开发(R&D)投资产生了寒蝉效应。随着全球范围内正在讨论和/或采用现代育种技术(如基因组编辑品种)的法规,我们希望提出一个框架,以确保小麦不会像以前一样再次被落下,因为其潜在的好处远远超过了人们对这些技术的感知风险。在本文中,在回顾了生成转基因和 cis- 基因小麦品种所面临的技术挑战之后,我们讨论了一些可能有助于揭开风险/回报等式的因素,从而使消费者对这些技术在未来小麦改良中的应用不再感到勉强或难以接受。新一代测序技术的出现揭示了物种之间自然基因转移的情况,以及其他一些被广泛接受的技术(如诱变)所产生的基因干扰数量。如果我们要开发出具有抗气候能力的小麦品种来养活不断增长的世界人口,那么从经典的育种技术过渡并采用转基因、cis- 基因和基因组编辑方法对于小麦改良来说感觉是不可避免的。