Adanan Nur Fadhilah Ain, Ooi Foong Kiew, Samsudin Norsuriani
Exercise and Sports Science Programme, School of Health Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kelantan, Malaysia.
Faculty of Hospitality, Tourism and Wellness, Universiti Malaysia Kelantan, Kelantan, Malaysia.
Malays J Med Sci. 2024 Aug;31(4):174-184. doi: 10.21315/mjms2024.31.4.14. Epub 2024 Aug 27.
Martial arts training is beneficial for improving physical fitness but the improvements can vary according to the type of martial art performed. This study investigated lung function, aerobic and anaerobic capacity, flexibility, muscular strength and power among male adolescents who were sedentary or who practiced taekwondo or wushu.
A total of 30 male adolescents living in the Kelantan state in Malaysia who were between 14 years old and 20 years old were enrolled and divided into three groups: i) sedentary (control), ii) taekwondo and iii) wushu. Each participant underwent a lung function test, 20 m shuttle run, Wingate anaerobic test and a Sit and Reach test, as well as tests of standing long jump power, handgrip, back and leg strength.
Relative to the sedentary control group, the wushu group had significantly higher values than the sedentary control group for fat free mass ( = 0.047), explosive leg power ( < 0.001), aerobic capacity ( < 0.001), forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV) ( = 0.021) and Wingate anaerobic capacity ( < 0.05). The taekwondo group also showed significantly greater values than the sedentary control group for explosive leg power ( = 0.018), forced vital capacity (FVC) ( = 0.014) and FEV ( < 0.001). The wushu group exhibited significantly higher explosive leg power ( = 0.010) and Wingate anaerobic capacity parameters including mean power ( = 0.001), anaerobic capacity ( < 0.001) and anaerobic power ( = 0.002) than the taekwondo group.
Engagement of male adolescents in wushu and taekwondo was associated with improved physiological profiles compared to those who were in the sedentary control group. Practice of wushu could result in greater explosive leg power and anaerobic capacities than taekwondo.
武术训练有助于提高身体素质,但训练效果会因所练武术类型的不同而有所差异。本研究调查了久坐不动的男性青少年以及练习跆拳道或武术的男性青少年的肺功能、有氧和无氧能力、柔韧性、肌肉力量和爆发力。
共有30名年龄在14岁至20岁之间、居住在马来西亚吉兰丹州的男性青少年参与研究,并被分为三组:i)久坐不动组(对照组),ii)跆拳道组,iii)武术组。每位参与者都接受了肺功能测试、20米穿梭跑测试、温盖特无氧测试、坐立前屈测试,以及立定跳远爆发力测试、握力测试、背部和腿部力量测试。
相对于久坐不动的对照组,武术组在去脂体重(P = 0.047)、腿部爆发力(P < 0.001)、有氧能力(P < 0.001)、一秒用力呼气量(FEV)(P = 0.021)和温盖特无氧能力(P < 0.05)方面的数值显著高于久坐不动的对照组。跆拳道组在腿部爆发力(P = 0.018)、用力肺活量(FVC)(P = 0.014)和FEV(P < 0.001)方面的数值也显著高于久坐不动的对照组。武术组在腿部爆发力(P = 0.010)和温盖特无氧能力参数(包括平均功率,P = 0.001;无氧能力,P < 0.001;无氧功率,P = 0.002)方面显著高于跆拳道组。
与久坐不动的对照组相比,男性青少年参与武术和跆拳道训练与生理状况的改善有关。练习武术比练习跆拳道能产生更大的腿部爆发力和无氧能力。