Silva S S, Rocha A, Ferreira L, Neto B, Dikmen D, Filipec S Vidacek, Satalic Z, Viegas C
GreenUPorto/Inov4Agro, Faculdade de Ciências da Nutrição e Alimentação da Universidade do Porto, Rua do Campo Alegre, n.º 823, Porto, 4150-180, Portugal.
Escola Superior de Tecnologia da Saúde, Instituto Politécnico de Lisboa, Av. D. João II, Lote 4.69.0.1 Parque das Nações, Lisboa, 1990-096, Portugal.
BMC Nutr. 2024 Dec 18;10(1):163. doi: 10.1186/s40795-024-00975-2.
The Mediterranean diet (MD) has been considered one of the healthiest dietary patterns, and an excellent model of sustainability. Higher Education food services present an excellent scenario to encourage students healthy eating habits and modulate food choices. The purpose of this work was to develop an index to evaluate MD compliance with cafeteria menus.
Three major axes were considered: MD key points, existing indexes on individual adherence to the MD and, existing indexes on menu assessment. The index includes four levels: (I) assesses the availability (IA), variety and frequency (IB) of food; (II) evaluates menu's nutritional quality; (III) assesses the menu's quality through information provided in the dishes' technical specifications and (IV) allows a more detailed evaluation through on-site visits and documentation consultation. The components receive a score between - 2 and 3, according to the given answers. The final score may vary between - 33.5 and 41.5 points depending on the degree of compliance with the MD key points. The index was applied to 60 menus from different contexts using complete assessments of each menu, performed independently by 3 researchers, using the same pre-prepared Microsoft Excel spreadsheet. Inter-rater reliability was assessed using Cohen's Kappa and internal consistency with Cronbach's alpha.
Assessment for level I) returned a Cohen's Kappa coefficient of 0.92 (p < 0.05) and a Cronbach's alpha coefficient of 0.88. Dimension I is mostly influenced by subdimension IB (r = 0,97). The availability of non-starchy vegetables and fresh fruits has a stronger correlation with IA (availability of foods), and higher availability of fish, pulses and fruit has a strong positive correlation with IB (variety and frequency of foods).
Researchers believe that the index is a useful tool to assess compliance of menus to the MD and help identify the key points that need to be addressed and improved in cafeterias.
地中海饮食(MD)被认为是最健康的饮食模式之一,也是可持续性的典范。高等教育餐饮服务为鼓励学生养成健康饮食习惯和调节食物选择提供了绝佳环境。本研究旨在开发一个评估自助餐厅菜单与地中海饮食契合度的指标。
考虑了三个主要方面:地中海饮食要点、个体遵循地中海饮食的现有指标以及菜单评估的现有指标。该指标包括四个级别:(I)评估食物的可获取性(IA)、种类和频率(IB);(II)评估菜单的营养质量;(III)通过菜品技术规格中提供的信息评估菜单质量;(IV)通过实地考察和文件查阅进行更详细的评估。根据给出的答案,各组成部分的得分在-2至3分之间。最终得分可能在-33.5至41.5分之间,具体取决于与地中海饮食要点的契合程度。该指标应用于来自不同背景的60份菜单,由3名研究人员独立使用相同的预先准备好的Microsoft Excel电子表格对每份菜单进行全面评估。使用科恩卡方系数评估评分者间信度,使用克朗巴哈系数评估内部一致性。
对级别I的评估得出科恩卡方系数为0.92(p < 0.05),克朗巴哈系数为0.88。维度I主要受子维度IB影响(r = 0.97)。非淀粉类蔬菜和新鲜水果的可获取性与IA(食物的可获取性)的相关性更强,鱼类、豆类和水果的较高可获取性与IB(食物的种类和频率)呈强正相关。
研究人员认为该指标是评估菜单与地中海饮食契合度的有用工具,有助于确定自助餐厅需要解决和改进的关键点。