Forestal Roberto Louis, Pi Shih-Ming
Department of Information Management Chung Yuan Christian University Taoyuan Taiwan.
J Multi Criteria Decis Anal. 2022 Jan-Apr;29(1-2):80-91. doi: 10.1002/mcda.1772. Epub 2021 Nov 15.
COVID-19 pandemic poses unprecedented challenges to the world health system, prompting academics and health professionals to develop appropriate solutions. Researchers reported different COVID-19 vaccines introduced by institutions and companies around the globe, which are at different stages of development. However, research developing an integrated framework for selecting and ranking the optimal potential vaccine against COVID-19 is minimal. This paper aimed to fill this gap by using a hybrid methodology based on ELimination Et Choice Translating REality III (ELECTRE III)-Genetic Algorithm (GA) and Technique of Order Preference Similarity to the Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) approach to select the optimal SARS-CoV-2 vaccine. ELECTRE III method yields a fathomable analysis of the concordance index, while GA is known for its ability to disaggregate decision-making preferences from holistic decisions. TOPSIS is preferred for picking an ideal and an anti-ideal solution. Thus, combining ELECTRE III-GA and TOPSIS is considered the best model to assess vaccines against the pandemic. The results confirm that the best vaccines rely on a high level of safety, efficacy, and availability. Our developed evaluation framework can help healthcare professionals and researchers gain research information and make critical decisions regarding potential vaccines against the disease.
新冠疫情给全球卫生系统带来了前所未有的挑战,促使学者和卫生专业人员寻求合适的解决方案。研究人员报告了全球各机构和公司推出的不同新冠疫苗,这些疫苗正处于不同的研发阶段。然而,针对开发一个用于筛选和排名对抗新冠病毒的最佳潜在疫苗的综合框架的研究却很少。本文旨在通过使用基于淘汰选择转换现实法III(ELECTRE III)-遗传算法(GA)和逼近理想解排序法(TOPSIS)的混合方法来填补这一空白,以筛选出最佳的严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒2(SARS-CoV-2)疫苗。ELECTRE III方法能对一致性指数进行深入分析,而GA则以其从整体决策中分解决策偏好的能力而闻名。TOPSIS则更适合用于挑选理想解和反理想解。因此,将ELECTRE III-GA和TOPSIS相结合被认为是评估针对该疫情的疫苗的最佳模型。结果证实,最佳疫苗依赖于高度的安全性、有效性和可及性。我们开发的评估框架可以帮助医疗保健专业人员和研究人员获取研究信息,并就针对该疾病的潜在疫苗做出关键决策。