Murray Maeve, Behan Stephen, Smith Craig, Goss Hannah
School of Health and Human Performance, Polaris Building, Dublin City University, Glasnevin, Dublin D09 V209, Ireland.
Insight Research Ireland Centre for Data Analytics, Polaris Building, Dublin City University, Dublin D09 V209, Ireland.
Health Promot Int. 2025 Jul 1;40(4). doi: 10.1093/heapro/daaf138.
Consistently, low health literacy has been found to lead to poorer health outcomes, both internationally, and in Ireland. Given this knowledge, there is a need to understand key thematic trends, methodological approaches and evidence gaps in policy and practice. Seven electronic databases (Science Direct, MEDLINE, CINAHL Complete, Web of Science, Scopus, PsychoINFO, and SPORTDiscus) were searched between October and December 2023 focusing on studies published in English between 2013 and 2023. Initial peer reviewed records (N = 551) were screened resulting in 37 studies included in this review. Narrative analysis indicated that across the island of Ireland many studies had narrow populations of focus (e.g. Dublin based, adults, chronic illness populations), limited research design and methodologies (e.g. cross-sectional, narrative, and primary research with short time frames), and lacked rigorous monitoring and evaluation of health literacy as a primary or secondary outcome. Future health literacy research in Ireland should consider: (i) contextual and sociodemographic factors (age, sex, ethnicity, socioeconomic status) when aiming to improve health literacy in different populations, (ii) exploring health literacy beyond the clinical domain, (iii) advocating for sustainability of effective programmes, and (iv) rigorous, longitudinal evaluation of health literacy. Quality research in these areas will support the meaningful and sustainable development of health literacy in Ireland, with findings that can be transferred internationally.
一直以来,无论是在国际上还是在爱尔兰,人们都发现健康素养低会导致更差的健康结果。基于这一认识,有必要了解政策和实践中的关键主题趋势、方法途径以及证据空白。在2023年10月至12月期间,对七个电子数据库(科学Direct、MEDLINE、CINAHL Complete、科学网、Scopus、PsychoINFO和SPORTDiscus)进行了检索,重点关注2013年至2023年期间以英文发表的研究。对初步同行评审记录(N =
551)进行了筛选,最终有37项研究纳入本综述。叙述性分析表明,在爱尔兰全岛,许多研究的关注人群范围狭窄(例如以都柏林为基础、成年人、慢性病患者群体),研究设计和方法有限(例如横断面研究、叙述性研究以及时间框架较短的初步研究),并且缺乏对健康素养作为主要或次要结果的严格监测和评估。爱尔兰未来的健康素养研究应考虑:(i)在旨在提高不同人群的健康素养时考虑背景和社会人口因素(年龄、性别、种族、社会经济地位),(ii)探索临床领域之外的健康素养,(iii)倡导有效项目的可持续性,以及(iv)对健康素养进行严格的纵向评估。这些领域的高质量研究将支持爱尔兰健康素养的有意义和可持续发展,其研究结果可在国际上推广。