Huffhines Lindsay, Silver Rebecca B, Low Christine M, Newland Rebecca, Herman Rachel, Ramirez Isai, Elwy A Rani, Parade Stephanie H
Department of Psychiatry and Human Behavior, Alpert Medical School of Brown University, Providence, RI, USA.
Bradley/Hasbro Children's Research Center, E. P. Bradley Hospital, East Providence, RI, USA.
Early Educ Dev. 2025;36(5):967-990. doi: 10.1080/10409289.2024.2424733. Epub 2024 Nov 10.
The positive impacts of Reflective Supervision (RS) are becoming increasingly evident. This approach may be especially important for early childhood teachers, who must deliver academic curricula and attend to children's social-emotional development while maintaining high-quality program standards in increasingly challenging environmental contexts. However, to effectively provide RS to early childhood teachers, supervisors must first be trained in this approach. This paper describes the results of one such innovative training effort using data from a statewide, community-based program evaluation and a pilot open trial in the United States. Participants (N = 83 supervisors) were offered foundational training in RS followed by monthly skill-building sessions. We used a concurrent mixed methods approach, integrating observational, survey, and interview data collected simultaneously to assess feasibility, acceptability, and preliminary effectiveness of the RS professional development series. Data integration was achieved through contiguous narrative and joint display approaches.
The RS series was feasible to implement, acceptable to participants, and led to improved reflective supervisory competencies.
The RS series may represent an opportunity to effectively support the early care and education workforce, and in turn, benefit children. We discuss some differences between samples that may be useful for future implementation efforts across early care and education settings.
反思性督导(RS)的积极影响日益明显。这种方法对幼儿教师可能尤为重要,因为他们必须在日益具有挑战性的环境中,既要教授学术课程,关注儿童的社会情感发展,又要维持高质量的项目标准。然而,要有效地为幼儿教师提供反思性督导,督导人员必须首先接受这种方法的培训。本文描述了一项此类创新培训工作的成果,该成果来自美国一项全州范围的、基于社区的项目评估以及一项试点开放试验的数据。参与者(N = 83名督导人员)接受了反思性督导的基础培训,随后每月参加技能提升课程。我们采用了同步混合方法,整合同时收集的观察、调查和访谈数据,以评估反思性督导专业发展系列的可行性、可接受性和初步效果。通过连贯叙述和联合展示方法实现了数据整合。
反思性督导系列实施起来可行,参与者能够接受,并且能提高反思性督导能力。
反思性督导系列可能是一个有效支持早期护理和教育工作人员的机会,进而使儿童受益。我们讨论了不同样本之间的一些差异,这些差异可能对未来在早期护理和教育环境中的实施工作有所帮助。