Scriver C R, Bardanis M, Cartier L, Clow C L, Lancaster G A, Ostrowsky J T
Am J Hum Genet. 1984 Sep;36(5):1024-38.
We report here an evaluation of a program for thalassemia-disease prevention, comprising education, population screening for heterozygotes, and reproductive counseling; the evaluation includes cost analysis. A preprogram survey in 1978 of 3,247 citizens in the high-risk communities (85% were high-school students) showed that 88% favored a program but that only 31% considered fetal diagnosis as an acceptable option. Screening in high school or before marriage was preferred by 56%. In a 25-month period (December 1979-December 1982), we screened 6,748 persons, including 5,117 senior high-school students, using MCV/HbA2 indices. The participation rate was 80% in the high-school group. The frequency for beta-thalassemia heterozygosity was 4.7% with 10-fold variation among ethnic groups at risk; the overall frequency for all variants found was 5.4%. We surveyed 60 carriers and 120 noncarriers after screening high-school students (response rate 77%): most carriers told parents (95%) and friends (67%) the test result; and 38% of the carriers' parents (vs. 18% of the noncarriers' parents) were also screened. Carriers would ascertain their spouses' genotype (91%) and approved uniformly (95%) the high-school screening experience and its goal. We performed 11 fetal diagnoses in a 25-month interval (greater than 75% participation in target population) either by fetoscopy and globin-chain analysis or by amniocentesis and genomic DNA analysis; two of three affected fetuses were aborted at parental request, there was one spontaneous abortion (after fetoscopy), and seven live births. The at-risk couples claimed pregnancy would not be contemplated without the fetal-diagnosis option. We analyzed economic costs of the program: cost per case prevented is approximately equal to $ 6,700, slightly less than cost-per-patient-treatment-year or about 4% of undiscounted treatment cost incurred in the first 25 years of life for an affected individual. These findings indicate: collective acceptance of the program, appropriate attitudes among carriers, general acceptance and efficacy of fetal diagnosis, and global cost-effectiveness.
我们在此报告一项地中海贫血疾病预防项目的评估情况,该项目包括教育、对杂合子进行人群筛查以及生育咨询;评估还包括成本分析。1978年对高危社区的3247名居民(85%为高中生)进行的项目前调查显示,88%的人支持该项目,但只有31%的人认为胎儿诊断是可接受的选择。56%的人倾向于在高中或婚前进行筛查。在25个月期间(1979年12月至1982年12月),我们使用平均红细胞体积/血红蛋白A2指数对6748人进行了筛查,其中包括5117名高中生。高中组的参与率为80%。β地中海贫血杂合子的频率为4.7%,在高危种族群体中有10倍的差异;所发现的所有变异的总体频率为5.4%。在对高中生进行筛查后,我们对60名携带者和120名非携带者进行了调查(回复率为77%):大多数携带者将检测结果告知了父母(95%)和朋友(67%);38%的携带者父母(而非携带者父母的这一比例为18%)也接受了筛查。携带者会确定其配偶的基因型(91%),并一致认可(95%)高中筛查经历及其目标。在25个月的间隔期内,我们通过胎儿镜检查和珠蛋白链分析或羊膜穿刺术和基因组DNA分析进行了11次胎儿诊断(目标人群参与率超过75%);三名受影响胎儿中有两名应父母要求流产,有一次自然流产(胎儿镜检查后),七名婴儿存活。高危夫妇声称,如果没有胎儿诊断选项,他们不会考虑怀孕。我们分析了该项目的经济成本:预防每例病例的成本约为6700美元,略低于每年每位患者的治疗成本,或约为受影响个体生命最初25年未折现治疗成本的4%。这些发现表明:该项目得到了集体认可,携带者态度恰当,胎儿诊断得到普遍接受且有效,以及总体成本效益良好。