Mazza J E, Newman M G, Sims T N
J Clin Periodontol. 1981 Jun;8(3):203-12. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-051x.1981.tb02031.x.
The antimicrobial effect of stannous fluoride (SnF2) on suspected pathogenic morphotypes of bacterial plaque in chronic periodontal disease was assessed. Alterations in morphological groups of subgingival and supragingival plaque bacteria from three diseased sites and one periodontally healthy site were determined by darkfield microscopy in 10 male patients with advanced periodontitis. In addition, clinical indices were also measured. The three diseased sites received either 1.64% SnF2, 0.4% SnF2 or sterile saline by subgingival irrigation. The healthy site received sterile saline only. The patients were seen weekly over a 10-week period and at each appointment bacterial sampling and clinical indices were measured. Results indicated that 1.64% SnF2 caused a dramatic and sustained decrease of subgingival motile bacteria and spirochetes following irrigation. By the sixth week these bacteria returned to 50% of their original concentration. Bleeding index scores, which were significantly reduced, correlated positively to the reduction in motile bacteria and spirochetes. Sites irrigated with 0.4% SnF2 also demonstrated a similar pattern of reduction of motile bacteria and spirochetes but without their total elimination and a more rapid return to original levels. In the diseased sites receiving sterile saline there was a decrease in motile bacteria and spirochetes, corresponding with saline irrigation, which rapidly returned to baseline levels. The healthy control sites were unchanged. Supragingival plaque index scores did not correlate with the bleeding index, motile bacteria and spirochetes, or with subgingival irrigation.
评估了氟化亚锡(SnF2)对慢性牙周病中可疑致病性菌斑形态型的抗菌作用。通过暗视野显微镜检查,确定了10名晚期牙周炎男性患者来自三个患病部位和一个牙周健康部位的龈下和龈上菌斑细菌形态学组的变化。此外,还测量了临床指标。三个患病部位通过龈下冲洗分别接受1.64% SnF2、0.4% SnF2或无菌盐水。健康部位仅接受无菌盐水。在10周的时间里,每周对患者进行检查,每次就诊时测量细菌样本和临床指标。结果表明,1.64% SnF2冲洗后导致龈下活动细菌和螺旋体急剧且持续减少。到第六周,这些细菌恢复到其原始浓度的50%。显著降低的出血指数评分与活动细菌和螺旋体的减少呈正相关。用0.4% SnF2冲洗的部位也显示出活动细菌和螺旋体类似的减少模式,但没有完全消除,且更快恢复到原始水平。在接受无菌盐水的患病部位,活动细菌和螺旋体减少,与盐水冲洗一致,且迅速恢复到基线水平。健康对照部位没有变化。龈上菌斑指数评分与出血指数、活动细菌和螺旋体或龈下冲洗均无相关性。