Walczak T S, Papacostas S, Williams D T, Scheuer M L, Lebowitz N, Notarfrancesco A
Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, Columbia Presbyterian Medical Center, New York, NY 10032, USA.
Epilepsia. 1995 Nov;36(11):1131-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1528-1157.1995.tb00472.x.
Information regarding outcome in patients with psychogenic nonepileptic seizures (PNES) is limited. We attempted to contact 72 consecutive patients with PNES confirmed by video-EEG monitoring: 51 of 72 (71%) were reached a mean of 15 months (range 12-27 months) after diagnosis and agreed to answer a structured telephone questionnaire. The questionnaire assessed the number of PNES in the last 6 months, antiepileptic drug (AED) use, occupational status, global self-rating, and extent of psychotherapeutic treatments. PNES had ceased in 18 of 51 (35%), decreased > 80% in 21 of 51 (41%), and decreased < 80% in 12 of 51 (24%). Thirty-three of 51 (65%) were not taking AEDs. Occupational status improved in 20% and did not change in 75%. Overall, 29 of 51 (57%) rated themselves markedly improved and 15 of 51 (29%) rated themselves unchanged or worse. Persisting PNES were associated with longer duration of PNES before diagnosis (p < 0.02) and presence of additional psychiatric disease (p < 0.01). Persisting PNES were not associated with gender, presence of epileptic seizures, or extent of psychotherapeutic treatments after diagnosis. Placebo saline infusion had been administered in some patients to help precipitate PNES. This did not affect the number of psychotherapy visits or outcome. We conclude that PNES cease or significantly decrease in most patients, but occupational status does not improve as often. Earlier diagnosis may improve outcome.
关于精神性非癫痫性发作(PNES)患者预后的信息有限。我们试图联系72例经视频脑电图监测确诊的连续性PNES患者:72例中有51例(71%)在诊断后平均15个月(范围12 - 27个月)被联系上,并同意回答一份结构化电话调查问卷。该问卷评估了过去6个月内PNES的发作次数、抗癫痫药物(AED)使用情况、职业状况、整体自我评分以及心理治疗的程度。51例患者中,18例(35%)的PNES已停止发作,21例(41%)减少超过80%,12例(24%)减少不足80%。51例中有33例(65%)未服用AED。20%的患者职业状况有所改善,75%未改变。总体而言,51例中有29例(57%)自我评估明显改善,15例(29%)自我评估无变化或变差。持续存在的PNES与诊断前PNES持续时间较长(p < 0.02)以及存在其他精神疾病(p < 0.01)有关。持续存在的PNES与性别、癫痫发作的存在或诊断后心理治疗的程度无关。一些患者接受了安慰剂生理盐水输注以诱发PNES。这并未影响心理治疗就诊次数或预后。我们得出结论,大多数患者的PNES会停止发作或显著减少,但职业状况改善的情况不常见。早期诊断可能改善预后。