Kane R L, Friedman B
Division of Health Services Research and Policy, University of Minnesota School of Public Health, Minneapolis 55455, USA.
Am J Public Health. 1997 Oct;87(10):1611-9. doi: 10.2105/ajph.87.10.1611.
This study examined variations in Medicare expenditures across states.
1992 data on average Medicare expenditures per enrollee, users of services per 1000 enrollees, service use per user, and payment per unit of service were compared across states for various services. Weighted least squares regression analysis was employed to examine total Medicare expenditures per enrollee by state.
Variation in Medicare expenditures across states is driven more by average number of service users per 1000 enrollees and average service units per user than by average payment per service unit. Medicare expenditures per enrollee by state are primarily a function of Medicare HMO penetration rate (P = .000), urban area (P = .001), hospital bed supply (P = .005), elderly mortality rate (P = .012), Medicare physician assignment rate (P = .026), percentage of primary care practitioners (P = .042), and interactions between urban elderly and percentage of primary care physicians (P = .005) and Black elderly and nursing home bed supply (P = .012).
Before sweeping Medicare cuts are undertaken or excessive reliance on managed care occurs, attention should be focused on the current disproportionate distribution of expenditures across states.
本研究调查了各州医疗保险支出的差异。
比较了1992年各州各类服务的以下数据:每位参保人的平均医疗保险支出、每1000名参保人的服务使用者数量、每位使用者的服务使用量以及每单位服务的支付费用。采用加权最小二乘法回归分析来研究各州每位参保人的医疗保险总支出。
各州医疗保险支出的差异更多是由每1000名参保人的平均服务使用者数量和每位使用者的平均服务单位数量驱动的,而非每单位服务的平均支付费用。各州每位参保人的医疗保险支出主要取决于医疗保险健康维护组织(HMO)的渗透率(P = 0.000)、城市地区(P = 0.001)、医院床位供应(P = 0.005)、老年人死亡率(P = 0.012)、医疗保险医生指派率(P = 0.026)、初级保健从业者的比例(P = 0.042),以及城市老年人与初级保健医生比例之间的相互作用(P = 0.005)和黑人老年人与疗养院床位供应之间的相互作用(P = 0.012)。
在大幅削减医疗保险或过度依赖管理式医疗之前,应关注当前各州支出分布不均衡的问题。