Neath I, Surprenant A M, LeCompte D C
Purdue University, West Lafayette, IN 47907-1364, USA.
Mem Cognit. 1998 Mar;26(2):343-54. doi: 10.3758/bf03201145.
The word length effect refers to the observation that memory is better for short than for long words. The irrelevant speech effect refers to the finding that memory is better when items are presented against a quiet background than against one with irrelevant speech. According to Baddeley's (1986, 1994) working memory, these variables should not interact: The word length effect arises from rehearsal by the articulatory control process, whereas irrelevant speech reduces recall through interference in the phonological store. Four experiments demonstrate that, like articulatory suppression, irrelevant speech eliminates the word length effect for both visual and auditory items. These results (1) provide further evidence against the ability of working memory to explain the word length and irrelevant speech effects and (2) confirm a specific prediction of Nairne's (1990) feature model.
对短单词的记忆比对长单词的记忆更好。无关言语效应是指这样一个发现:当项目在安静背景下呈现时比在有无关言语的背景下呈现时,记忆效果更好。根据巴德利(1986年、1994年)的工作记忆理论,这些变量不应相互作用:词长效应源于发音控制过程的复述,而无关言语通过干扰语音存储来降低回忆效果。四项实验表明,与发音抑制一样,无关言语消除了视觉和听觉项目的词长效应。这些结果(1)进一步证明了工作记忆无法解释词长效应和无关言语效应,(2)证实了奈恩(1990年)特征模型的一个具体预测。