Villar J, Gülmezoglu A M, de Onis M
UNDP/UNFPA/WHO/World Bank Special Programme of Research, Development and Research Training in Human Reproduction, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Obstet Gynecol Surv. 1998 Sep;53(9):575-85. doi: 10.1097/00006254-199809000-00025.
The study was conducted to assess the effectiveness of interventions for the prevention or treatment of nutritional and infectious disorders during pregnancy on preterm birth rates. Cochrane systematic reviews or any other more up-to-date systematic review of antimicrobial and nutritional interventions were sought. Electronic searches of the Cochrane Controlled Trials Register were carried out to identify any trials published since the most recent update of the systematic review. Also, authors of Cochrane systematic reviews, which have not been updated recently, were contacted regarding new information. Systematic reviews of nutritional and antimicrobial interventions during pregnancy, reporting preterm delivery rates (delivery before 37 weeks) and "prematurity" (including low birth weight) either as primary or secondary outcomes, were included. General interventions without a specific nutritional supplementation or antimicrobial component were not considered for inclusion. Interventions to stop labor or prolong pregnancy after a diagnosis of preterm labor were excluded. For each systematic review, data on preterm delivery rate by intervention group was obtained. The total number of trials in the review, number of trials reporting preterm birth as an outcome, number of participants and events have been systematically extracted. Eighteen systematic reviews (10 nutritional and 8 antimicrobial) were considered. Our results indicated that, overall, the treatment of asymptomatic bacteriuria reduces the incidence of preterm birth or low birth weight (< 2500 gm) (typical relative risk (RR): 0.67; 95 percent confidence interval (CI): 0.52-0.85). The protective effect of treating asymptomatic bacteriuria for preterm delivery persisted when only the three trials reporting preterm delivery (< 37 weeks) were included in the meta-analysis (typical RR: 0.53, 95 percent CI: 0.33-0.86). Routine iron supplementation prevents maternal anemia and one trial comparing routine versus selective iron supplementation showed a statistically nonsignificant reduction in preterm birth. Zinc, magnesium, and fish oil supplementations show promising results in reducing preterm birth, but the evidence is not strong. Calcium supplementation remains controversial, although there was a statistically significant reduction in preterm delivery in the subgroup of women at high risk of developing hypertension during pregnancy. Two trials with use of metronidazole (alone or with erythromycin) showed a reduction in preterm delivery in women who were at a high risk of preterm delivery and had bacterial vaginosis at screening. We have concluded that asymptomatic bacteriuria should be screened and treated in all settings that offer antenatal care. Single dose treatment seems to be as effective as longer (4-7 days) treatment, although this needs to be confirmed by a large, methodologically rigorous trial. There are a number of promising interventions such as calcium supplementation in women with low calcium intake, iron, zinc, magnesium, and fish oil supplementation, and treatment of bacterial vaginosis in women at high risk of preterm delivery that need additional research to determine a possible role for prevention of preterm delivery.
本研究旨在评估孕期预防或治疗营养及感染性疾病的干预措施对早产率的有效性。我们检索了Cochrane系统评价或任何其他关于抗菌和营养干预措施的更新的系统评价。对Cochrane对照试验注册库进行了电子检索,以识别自系统评价的最新更新以来发表的任何试验。此外,还就新信息联系了近期未更新的Cochrane系统评价的作者。纳入了孕期营养和抗菌干预措施的系统评价,这些评价将早产率(37周前分娩)和“早产”(包括低出生体重)作为主要或次要结局进行报告。不考虑纳入无特定营养补充或抗菌成分的一般干预措施。排除诊断为早产临产之后为停止分娩或延长孕期的干预措施。对于每项系统评价,获取干预组的早产率数据。系统提取了评价中的试验总数、将早产作为结局报告的试验数、参与者数量和事件数量。共考虑了18项系统评价(10项营养相关和8项抗菌相关)。我们的结果表明,总体而言,无症状菌尿的治疗可降低早产或低出生体重(<2500克)的发生率(典型相对危险度(RR):0·67;95%置信区间(CI):0·52 - 0·85)。当荟萃分析仅纳入三项报告早产(<37周)的试验时,无症状菌尿治疗对早产的保护作用仍然存在(典型RR:0·53,95%CI:0·33 - 0·86)。常规铁剂补充可预防母体贫血,一项比较常规与选择性铁剂补充的试验显示早产率有统计学上无显著意义的降低。锌、镁和鱼油补充剂在降低早产方面显示出有前景的结果,但证据并不充分。钙剂补充仍存在争议,尽管在孕期有高血压高风险的女性亚组中早产分娩有统计学上的显著降低。两项使用甲硝唑(单独或与红霉素联用)的试验显示,在筛查时有细菌性阴道病且早产高风险的女性中,早产分娩有所减少。我们得出结论,在所有提供产前护理的机构中都应筛查和治疗无症状菌尿。单剂量治疗似乎与较长疗程(4 - 7天)治疗一样有效,尽管这需要通过一项大型、方法学严谨的试验来证实。有许多有前景的干预措施,如钙摄入量低的女性补充钙剂、补充铁、锌、镁和鱼油,以及对早产高风险女性的细菌性阴道病进行治疗,这些都需要进一步研究以确定其在预防早产方面可能发挥的作用。