Izquierdo Mikel, Ibañez Javier, HAkkinen Keijo, Kraemer William J, Larrión José L, Gorostiaga Esteban M
Studies, Research and Sports Medicine Center, Government of Navarra, Spain.
Med Sci Sports Exerc. 2004 Mar;36(3):435-43. doi: 10.1249/01.mss.0000117897.55226.9a.
To compare the effects of the 16-wk training period (2 d.wk(-1)) of resistance training alone (S), endurance training alone (E), or combined resistance (once weekly) and endurance (once weekly) training (SE) on muscle mass, maximal strength and power of the leg and arm extensor muscles, and maximal workload (Wmax) by using a incremental cycling test in older men.
Thirty-one healthy men (65-74 yr) were divided into three treatment groups to train 2x wk(-1) for 16 wk: S (N = 10), E (N = 11), or SE (N = 10; 1x wk(-1) S + 1x wk(-1) E). The subjects were tested at 8-wk intervals (i.e., weeks 8 and 16).
There were no significant differences between S- and SE-induced muscle hypertrophy (11% and 11%) and maximal strength (41% and 38%) gains of the legs as well as between E- and SE-induced Wmax (28% and 23%) gains. The increase in arm strength in S (36%) was greater than that recorded in SE (22%) and greater than that recorded in E (0%).
Prolonged combined resistance and endurance training in older men seemed to lead to similar gains in muscle mass, maximal strength, and power of the legs as resistance training alone and to similar gains in maximal peak power output measured in an incremental cycling test as endurance training alone. These findings may have an effect on how resistance exercise is prescribed to older adults.
通过递增式自行车测试,比较16周训练期(每周2天)的单纯抗阻训练(S组)、单纯耐力训练(E组)或联合抗阻(每周1次)与耐力(每周1次)训练(SE组)对老年男性腿部和手臂伸肌的肌肉质量、最大力量和功率,以及最大工作量(Wmax)的影响。
31名健康男性(65 - 74岁)被分为三个治疗组,每周训练2次,共16周:S组(N = 10)、E组(N = 11)或SE组(N = 10;每周1次抗阻训练 + 每周1次耐力训练)。受试者每隔8周(即第8周和第16周)进行测试。
S组和SE组在腿部肌肉肥大(分别为11%和11%)和最大力量增加(分别为41%和38%)方面,以及E组和SE组在Wmax增加(分别为28%和23%)方面,均无显著差异。S组手臂力量的增加(36%)大于SE组(22%),且大于E组(0%)。
老年男性长期进行联合抗阻和耐力训练,在肌肉质量、最大力量和腿部功率增加方面似乎与单纯抗阻训练相似,在递增式自行车测试中测得的最大峰值功率输出增加方面与单纯耐力训练相似。这些发现可能会影响为老年人制定抗阻运动处方的方式。