Bunta Ferenc, Ingram David
Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona, USA.
J Speech Lang Hear Res. 2007 Aug;50(4):999-1014. doi: 10.1044/1092-4388(2007/070).
In this study, the authors investigated speech rhythm acquisition by bilingual Spanish-English-speaking children, comparing their performance with functionally monolingual peers in both languages and to monolingual and bilingual adults.
Participants included younger children (3;9 [years;months] to 4;5.15[years;months.days]), older children (4;6.18 to 5;2), and adults (over 18 years). Twenty-six sentences were elicited and analyzed using the normalized vocalic and intervocalic Pairwise Variability Indices (PVIs) that express the level of variability in successive duration measurements, on the basis of E. Grabe and E. L. Low (2002).
Younger bilingual children displayed distinct speech rhythm patterns for their target languages, and they deviated from their monolingual English-speaking peers. Older bilingual children also separated speech rhythm by language, and differences between older bilingual children and their monolingual peers speaking English were also found. Younger and older bilingual children differed on the vocalic PVI, but not the intervocalic PVI, providing partial support for age differences. Bilingual adults showed separation of their languages and performed similarly to their monolingual peers.
Bilingual children show distinct speech rhythm patterns for their target languages but with some early equal timing bias that diminishes over time, on the basis of the vocalic measurements. Overall, the vocalic PVI is more robust than the intervocalic PVI, but further research is necessary.
在本研究中,作者调查了说西班牙语和英语的双语儿童的言语节奏习得情况,将他们的表现与两种语言中功能上为单语的同龄人以及单语和双语成年人进行比较。
参与者包括年幼儿童(3岁9个月至4岁5个月15天)、年长儿童(4岁6个月18天至5岁2个月)和成年人(18岁以上)。根据E. 格拉贝和E. L. 洛(2002年)的研究,引出并分析了26个句子,使用归一化元音和元音间成对变异指数(PVI)来表达连续时长测量中的变异程度。
年幼儿童在其目标语言中表现出独特的言语节奏模式,且与说英语的单语同龄人不同。年长儿童也按语言区分言语节奏,且年长双语儿童与其说英语的单语同龄人之间也存在差异。年幼儿童和年长儿童在元音PVI上存在差异,但在元音间PVI上没有差异,这为年龄差异提供了部分支持。双语成年人表现出语言区分,且表现与他们的单语同龄人相似。
根据元音测量结果,双语儿童在其目标语言中表现出独特的言语节奏模式,但存在一些早期的等时偏差,且这种偏差会随着时间推移而减小。总体而言,元音PVI比元音间PVI更可靠,但仍需进一步研究。