Verano L, Michalski F J
MetPath, Inc., Corning Laboratory Sciences, Teterboro, New Jersey 07608.
J Clin Microbiol. 1990 Nov;28(11):2555-8. doi: 10.1128/jcm.28.11.2555-2558.1990.
A commercial 5-h direct herpes simplex virus (HSV) antigen detection enzyme immunoassay kit (Du Pont Herpchek) was compared with a cell culture isolation system by using primary rabbit kidney and MRC-5 cells with 779 clinical specimens received in virus transport medium and with stock tissue culture preparations of HSV types 1 and 2. In the first study of 422 specimens from symptomatic patients, Herpchek detected 110 of 111 HSV-positive specimens (26.3% of all specimens), with a sensitivity of 99% and a specificity of 100%. In the second study of 357 specimens primarily from asymptomatic pregnant women, however, Herpchek detected 70 of 119 HSV-positive specimens (33% of all specimens), with a sensitivity of 58.8% and a specificity of 99.5%. Stock virus dilution experiments showed that Herpchek was 10 to 100 times less sensitive than culture. Herpchek was found to be an acceptable test for symptomatic patients, but for asymptomatic patients shedding a low titer of HSV it was not as sensitive and cell culture of Herpchek-negative specimens is recommended for such cases.
采用商业性的5小时单纯疱疹病毒(HSV)抗原检测酶免疫分析试剂盒(杜邦疱疹检测试剂盒),与细胞培养分离系统进行比较。所用材料包括用病毒运送培养基接收的779份临床标本接种的原代兔肾细胞和MRC-5细胞,以及1型和2型HSV的组织培养储备制剂。在对422份有症状患者标本的第一项研究中,疱疹检测试剂盒检测出111份HSV阳性标本中的110份(占所有标本的26.3%),灵敏度为99%,特异性为100%。然而,在对主要来自无症状孕妇的357份标本的第二项研究中,疱疹检测试剂盒检测出119份HSV阳性标本中的70份(占所有标本的33%),灵敏度为58.8%,特异性为99.5%。储备病毒稀释实验表明,疱疹检测试剂盒的灵敏度比培养法低10至100倍。对于有症状患者,疱疹检测试剂盒是一项可接受的检测方法,但对于HSV滴度较低的无症状患者,其灵敏度不够,对于此类病例,建议对疱疹检测试剂盒检测阴性的标本进行细胞培养。