Department of Mathematics, University of Manitoba, Winnipeg, MB.
Can J Public Health. 2011 Jul-Aug;102(4):294-7. doi: 10.1007/BF03404053.
We assessed the performance of syndromic indicators based on Google Flu Trends (GFT) and emergency department (ED) data for the early detection and monitoring of the 2009 H1N1 pandemic waves in Manitoba.
Time-series curves for the weekly counts of laboratory-confirmed H1N1 cases in Manitoba during the 2009 pandemic were plotted against the three syndromic indicators: 1) GFT data, based on flu-related Internet search queries, 2) weekly count of all ED visits triaged as influenza-like illness (ED ILI volume), and 3) percentage of all ED visits that were triaged as an ILI (ED ILI percent). A linear regression model was fitted separately for each indicator and correlations with weekly virologic data were calculated for different lag periods for each pandemic wave.
All three indicators peaked 1-2 weeks earlier than the epidemic curve of laboratory-confirmed cases. For GFT data, the best-fitting model had about a 2-week lag period in relation to the epidemic curve. Similarly, the best-fitting models for both ED indicators were observed for a time lag of 1-2 weeks. All three indicators performed better as predictors of the virologic time trends during the second wave as compared to the first. There was strong congruence between the time series of the GFT and both the ED ILI volume and the ED ILI percent indicators.
During an influenza season characterized by high levels of disease activity, GFT and ED indicators provided a good indication of weekly counts of laboratory-confirmed influenza cases in Manitoba 1-2 weeks in advance.
我们评估了基于 Google 流感趋势(GFT)和急诊数据的综合征指标在曼尼托巴省 2009 年 H1N1 大流行波的早期检测和监测中的表现。
绘制了曼尼托巴省 2009 年大流行期间每周实验室确诊的 H1N1 病例数与三个综合征指标的时间序列曲线:1)GFT 数据,基于与流感相关的互联网搜索查询,2)每周所有分诊为流感样疾病(ED ILI 量)的急诊就诊人数,3)所有分诊为 ILI 的急诊就诊人数百分比(ED ILI 百分比)。为每个指标分别拟合线性回归模型,并计算不同大流行波的不同滞后期与每周病毒学数据的相关性。
所有三个指标都比实验室确诊病例的流行曲线提前 1-2 周达到峰值。对于 GFT 数据,最佳拟合模型与流行曲线的滞后时间约为 2 周。同样,对于 ED 指标的最佳拟合模型,观察到的滞后时间为 1-2 周。与第一波相比,所有三个指标在预测病毒学时间趋势方面在第二波表现更好。GFT 与 ED ILI 量和 ED ILI 百分比两个指标的时间序列之间存在很强的一致性。
在疾病活动水平较高的流感季节,GFT 和 ED 指标能够很好地预测曼尼托巴省每周实验室确诊流感病例数,提前 1-2 周。