van Heuven Walter J B, Conklin Kathy, Coderre Emily L, Guo Taomei, Dijkstra Ton
School of Psychology, University of Nottingham Nottingham, UK.
Front Psychol. 2011 Dec 13;2:374. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2011.00374. eCollection 2011.
This study investigated effects of cross-language similarity on within- and between-language Stroop interference and facilitation in three groups of trilinguals. Trilinguals were either proficient in three languages that use the same-script (alphabetic in German-English-Dutch trilinguals), two similar scripts and one different script (Chinese and alphabetic scripts in Chinese-English-Malay trilinguals), or three completely different scripts (Arabic, Chinese, and alphabetic in Uyghur-Chinese-English trilinguals). The results revealed a similar magnitude of within-language Stroop interference for the three groups, whereas between-language interference was modulated by cross-language similarity. For the same-script trilinguals, the within- and between-language interference was similar, whereas the between-language Stroop interference was reduced for trilinguals with languages written in different scripts. The magnitude of within-language Stroop facilitation was similar across the three groups of trilinguals, but smaller than within-language Stroop interference. Between-language Stroop facilitation was also modulated by cross-language similarity such that these effects became negative for trilinguals with languages written in different scripts. The overall pattern of Stroop interference and facilitation effects can be explained in terms of diverging and converging color and word information across languages.
本研究调查了跨语言相似性对三组三语者在同语言和跨语言Stroop干扰及促进效应方面的影响。三语者要么精通使用相同文字的三种语言(德 - 英 - 荷三语者使用字母文字),要么精通两种相似文字和一种不同文字(汉 - 英 - 马来三语者使用中文和字母文字),要么精通三种完全不同的文字(维吾尔 - 汉 - 英三语者使用阿拉伯文、中文和字母文字)。结果显示,三组同语言Stroop干扰的程度相似,而跨语言干扰则受跨语言相似性的调节。对于使用相同文字的三语者,同语言和跨语言干扰相似,而对于使用不同文字的三语者,跨语言Stroop干扰则有所减少。三组三语者同语言Stroop促进效应的程度相似,但小于同语言Stroop干扰。跨语言Stroop促进效应也受跨语言相似性的调节,以至于对于使用不同文字的三语者,这些效应变为负面。Stroop干扰和促进效应的总体模式可以根据不同语言中颜色和单词信息的发散和收敛来解释。