Department of Earth and Environment, Florida International University, Miami, 33199, USA.
Environ Manage. 2012 Aug;50(2):181-90. doi: 10.1007/s00267-012-9896-4. Epub 2012 Jun 17.
Implementation of policy involves multiple agencies operating at multiple levels in facilitating processes and actions to accomplish desired results. The Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) was developed and implemented to regulate and control international wildlife trade, but violations of the agreement are widespread and growing worldwide, including in Nepal. This study attempts to understand how domestic CITES policies are translated into action and what effect actions and processes have on compliance. In doing so, this study provides insights into the implementation and enforcement pitfalls of national legislation that explain CITES violations in Nepal. Primarily, we used 26 key informants interviews to learn opinions of experts, and the grounded theory approach for further qualitative data analysis. In addition, we used Najman's (1995) policy implementation analysis framework to explain gaps. Many interrelated variables in the content of the policy, commitment and capacity of the agencies, the roles of clients and coalitions and contextual issues were observed. Variables that emerged suggest pitfalls in the regulatory policy represented by low probability of detection, arrest and punishment. Moreover, redistributive policies in buffer zones of protected areas are needed into perpetuity to benefit locals. Also, conservation organizations' support for building public and political salience is imperative.
实施政策涉及多个机构在多个层面上运作,以促进实现预期结果的过程和行动。《濒危野生动植物种国际贸易公约》(CITES)的制定和实施是为了规范和控制国际野生动植物贸易,但全球范围内,包括尼泊尔在内,违反该协议的行为屡见不鲜且呈上升趋势。本研究试图了解国内 CITES 政策如何转化为行动,以及行动和流程对合规性的影响。为此,本研究深入了解了导致尼泊尔违反 CITES 协议的国家立法的执行和执法缺陷。主要采用 26 名关键知情者访谈来了解专家的意见,并使用扎根理论方法进一步进行定性数据分析。此外,我们使用 Najman(1995)的政策实施分析框架来解释差距。在政策内容、机构的承诺和能力、客户和联盟的作用以及背景问题等方面,观察到许多相互关联的变量。出现的变量表明监管政策存在漏洞,检测、逮捕和惩罚的可能性较低。此外,需要在保护区缓冲区实行永久的再分配政策,以使当地人受益。此外,保护组织支持建立公众和政治关注度至关重要。