Department of Biomedical Engineering, Marquette University, Milwaukee, USA.
Ophthalmic Physiol Opt. 2013 Jul;33(4):540-9. doi: 10.1111/opo.12070. Epub 2013 May 13.
An impediment for the clinical utilisation of ophthalmic adaptive optics imaging systems is the automated assessment of photoreceptor mosaic integrity. Here we propose a fully automated algorithm for estimating photoreceptor density based on the radius of Yellott's ring.
The discrete Fourier transform (DFT) was used to obtain the power spectrum for a series of images of the human photoreceptor mosaic. Cell spacing is estimated by least-square fitting an annular pattern with a Gaussian cross section to the power spectrum; the radius of the resulting annulus provides an estimate of the modal spacing of the photoreceptors in the retinal image. The intrasession repeatability of the cone density estimates from the algorithm was evaluated, and the accuracy of the algorithm was validated against direct count estimates from a previous study. Accuracy in the presence of multiple cell types and disruptions in the mosaic was examined using images from four patients with retinal pathology and perifoveal images from two subjects with normal vision.
Intrasession repeatability of the power spectrum method was comparable to a fully automated direct counting algorithm, but worse than that for the manually adjusted direct count values. In images of the normal parafoveal cone mosaic, we find good agreement between the power-spectrum derived density and that from the direct counting algorithm. In diseased eyes, the power spectrum method is insensitive to photoreceptor loss, with cone density estimates overestimating the density determined with direct counting. The automated power spectrum method also produced unreliable estimates of rod and cone density in perifoveal images of the photoreceptor mosaic, though manual correction of the initial algorithm output results in density estimates in better agreement with direct count values.
We developed and validated an automated algorithm based on the power spectrum for extracting estimates of cone spacing, from which estimates of density can be derived. This approach may be used to estimate cone density in images where not every single cone is visible, though caution is needed, as this robustness becomes a weakness when dealing with images from patients with some retinal diseases. This study represents an important first step in carefully assessing the relative utility of metrics for analysing the photoreceptor mosaic, and similar analyses of other metrics/algorithms are needed.
眼科自适应光学成像系统在临床应用中的一个障碍是自动评估光感受器镶嵌完整性。在这里,我们提出了一种基于 Yellott 环半径的全自动算法,用于估计光感受器密度。
离散傅里叶变换(DFT)用于获取一系列人眼光感受器镶嵌图像的功率谱。通过最小二乘拟合具有高斯截面的环形图案来估计细胞间距;所得环的半径提供了视网膜图像中光感受器的模态间距的估计值。评估了算法从单次会话中获得的锥体细胞密度估计的可重复性,并根据先前研究中的直接计数估计值验证了算法的准确性。使用来自四名视网膜病变患者的图像以及两名正常视力受试者的周边图像,检查了该算法在存在多种细胞类型和镶嵌中断时的准确性。
与全自动直接计数算法相比,功率谱方法的单次会话重复性相当,但不如手动调整的直接计数值重复性好。在正常周边凹锥体细胞镶嵌图像中,我们发现功率谱法得到的密度与直接计数算法得到的密度之间存在很好的一致性。在患病眼中,光感受器密度的功率谱法对光感受器丧失不敏感,锥体细胞密度的估计值高估了直接计数确定的密度。该自动功率谱方法在周边凹光感受器镶嵌的周边图像中也产生了不可靠的杆状细胞和锥体细胞密度估计值,尽管通过手动校正初始算法输出可以得到与直接计数值更一致的密度估计值。
我们开发并验证了一种基于功率谱的自动算法,用于提取锥体细胞间距的估计值,从中可以推导出密度估计值。这种方法可用于估计不是每个单独的锥体细胞都可见的图像中的锥体细胞密度,不过需要谨慎,因为当处理来自某些视网膜疾病患者的图像时,这种稳健性会成为一个弱点。这项研究代表了仔细评估用于分析光感受器镶嵌的度量标准的相对效用的重要的第一步,还需要对其他度量标准/算法进行类似的分析。