Li Xingshan, Bicknell Klinton, Liu Pingping, Wei Wei, Rayner Keith
Laboratory of Behavioral Science, Institute of Psychology, Chinese Academy of Sciences.
Department of Psychology, University of California.
J Exp Psychol Gen. 2014 Apr;143(2):895-913. doi: 10.1037/a0033580. Epub 2013 Jul 8.
While much previous work on reading in languages with alphabetic scripts has suggested that reading is word-based, reading in Chinese has been argued to be less reliant on words. This is primarily because in the Chinese writing system words are not spatially segmented, and characters are themselves complex visual objects. Here, we present a systematic characterization of the effects of a wide range of word and character properties on eye movements in Chinese reading, using a set of mixed-effects regression models. The results reveal a rich pattern of effects of the properties of the current, previous, and next words on a range of reading measures, which is strikingly similar to the pattern of effects of word properties reported in spaced alphabetic languages. This finding provides evidence that reading shares a word-based core and may be fundamentally similar across languages with highly dissimilar scripts. We show that these findings are robust to the inclusion of character properties in the regression models and are equally reliable when dependent measures are defined in terms of characters rather than words, providing strong evidence that word properties have effects in Chinese reading above and beyond characters. This systematic characterization of the effects of word and character properties in Chinese advances our knowledge of the processes underlying reading and informs the future development of models of reading. More generally, however, this work suggests that differences in script may not alter the fundamental nature of reading.
虽然之前许多关于字母文字阅读的研究表明阅读是以单词为基础的,但有人认为中文阅读对单词的依赖程度较低。这主要是因为在中文书写系统中,单词没有在空间上进行分割,而且汉字本身就是复杂的视觉对象。在这里,我们使用一组混合效应回归模型,对广泛的单词和汉字属性对中文阅读中眼动的影响进行了系统的表征。结果揭示了当前、前一个和下一个单词的属性对一系列阅读指标产生的丰富影响模式,这与间隔字母语言中报告的单词属性的影响模式惊人地相似。这一发现提供了证据,表明阅读共享一个以单词为基础的核心,并且在具有非常不同文字的语言中可能在根本上是相似的。我们表明,这些发现在回归模型中纳入汉字属性时是稳健的,并且当相关测量以汉字而不是单词来定义时同样可靠,这提供了有力的证据,证明单词属性在中文阅读中的影响超出了汉字。对中文中单词和汉字属性影响的这种系统表征推进了我们对阅读基础过程的认识,并为阅读模型的未来发展提供了信息。然而,更普遍地说,这项工作表明文字的差异可能不会改变阅读的基本性质。