Coderre Emily L, van Heuven Walter J B
School of Psychology, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2014 Jul 28;9(7):e103424. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0103424. eCollection 2014.
Bilinguals have been shown to exhibit a performance advantage on executive control tasks, outperforming their monolingual counterparts. Although a wealth of research has investigated this 'bilingual advantage' behaviourally, electrophysiological correlates are lacking. Using EEG with a Stroop task that manipulated the stimulus onset asynchrony (SOA) of word and colour presentation, the current study addressed two facets of the bilingual advantage. The possibility that bilinguals experience superior conflict processing relative to monolinguals (a 'conflict-specific advantage') was investigated by comparing behavioural interference effects as well as the amplitude of the Ninc, a conflict-related ERP component occurring from approximately 300-500 ms after the onset of conflict. In contrast, the hypothesis that bilinguals experience domain-general, conflict-independent enhancements in executive processing (a 'non-conflict-specific advantage') was evaluated by comparing the control condition (symbol strings) between groups. There was some significant, but inconsistent, evidence for a conflict-specific bilingual advantage. In contrast, strong evidence emerged for a non-conflict-specific advantage, with bilinguals demonstrating faster RTs and reduced ERP amplitudes on control trials compared to monolinguals. Importantly, when the control stimulus was presented before the colour, ERPs to control trials revealed group differences before the onset of conflict, suggesting differences in the ability to ignore or suppress distracting irrelevant information. This indicates that bilinguals experience superior executive processing even in the absence of conflict and semantic salience, and suggests that the advantage extends to more efficient proactive management of the environment.
双语者在执行控制任务中表现出优势,优于单语者。尽管大量研究从行为学角度对这种“双语优势”进行了调查,但缺乏电生理相关性研究。本研究采用脑电图结合一种操纵单词和颜色呈现的刺激起始异步性(SOA)的斯特鲁普任务,探讨了双语优势的两个方面。通过比较行为干扰效应以及Ninc的波幅(Ninc是冲突发生后约300 - 500毫秒出现的与冲突相关的事件相关电位成分),研究了双语者相对于单语者是否具有更好的冲突处理能力(“特定冲突优势”)。相比之下,通过比较两组之间的控制条件(符号串),评估了双语者在执行加工中是否具有领域通用的、与冲突无关的增强能力(“非特定冲突优势”)这一假设。有一些显著但不一致的证据支持特定冲突双语优势。相比之下,出现了有力证据支持非特定冲突优势,与单语者相比,双语者在控制试验中反应时更快,事件相关电位波幅更小。重要的是,当控制刺激在颜色之前呈现时,控制试验的事件相关电位在冲突开始前就显示出组间差异,这表明在忽略或抑制干扰性无关信息的能力方面存在差异。这表明双语者即使在没有冲突和语义显著性的情况下也具有更好的执行加工能力,并且表明这种优势扩展到对环境更有效的主动管理。