Hepburn Charlotte Moore, Cohen Eyal, Bhawra Jasmin, Weiser Natalie, Hayeems Robin Z, Guttmann Astrid
Division of Paediatric Medicine, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Ontario, Canada Department of Paediatrics, Child Health Policy Initiative, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Division of Paediatric Medicine, The Hospital for Sick Children, Toronto, Ontario, Canada Department of Paediatrics, Child Health Policy Initiative, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada Institute of Health Policy, Management, and Evaluation, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Arch Dis Child. 2015 Jun;100(6):559-64. doi: 10.1136/archdischild-2014-307320. Epub 2015 Feb 16.
The transition from paediatric to adult care is associated with poor clinical outcomes, increased costs and low patient and family satisfaction. However, little is known about health system strategies to streamline and safeguard care for youth transitioning to adult services. Moreover, the needs of children and youth are often excluded from broader health system reform discussions, leaving this population especially vulnerable to system 'disintegration'.
(1) To explore the international policy profile of paediatric-to-adult care transitions, and (2) to document policy objectives, initiatives and outcomes for jurisdictions publicly committed to addressing transition issues.
An international policy scoping review of all publicly available government documents detailing transition-related strategies was completed using a web-based search. Our analysis included a comparable cohort of nine wealthy Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) jurisdictions with Beveridge-style healthcare systems (deemed those most likely to benefit from system-level transition strategies).
Few jurisdictions address transition of care issues in either health or broader social policy documents. While many jurisdictions refer to standardised practice guidelines, a few report the intention to use powerful policy levers (including physician remuneration and non-physician investments) to facilitate the uptake of best practice. Most jurisdictions do not address the policy infrastructure required to support successful transitions, and rigorous evaluations of transition strategies are rare.
Despite the well-documented risks and costs associated with a poor transition from paediatric to adult care, little policy attention has been paid to this issue. We recommend that healthcare providers engage health system planners in the design and evaluation of system-level, policy-sensitive transition strategies.
从儿科护理向成人护理的过渡与临床效果不佳、成本增加以及患者和家庭满意度低有关。然而,对于简化和保障向成人服务过渡的青少年护理的卫生系统策略,我们知之甚少。此外,儿童和青少年的需求在更广泛的卫生系统改革讨论中常常被忽视,这使得这一人群特别容易受到系统“瓦解”的影响。
(1)探讨儿科到成人护理过渡的国际政策概况,(2)记录公开承诺解决过渡问题的司法管辖区的政策目标、举措和成果。
通过基于网络的搜索,对所有公开可用的详细说明与过渡相关策略的政府文件进行了国际政策范围审查。我们的分析包括九个拥有贝弗里奇式医疗保健系统的经济合作与发展组织(经合组织)富裕司法管辖区的可比队列(被认为最有可能从系统层面的过渡策略中受益)。
很少有司法管辖区在卫生或更广泛的社会政策文件中涉及护理过渡问题。虽然许多司法管辖区提到了标准化实践指南,但少数报告了使用有力政策杠杆(包括医生薪酬和非医生投资)来促进最佳实践采用的意图。大多数司法管辖区没有涉及支持成功过渡所需的政策基础设施,对过渡策略的严格评估也很少见。
尽管有充分记录表明从儿科护理向成人护理过渡不佳会带来风险和成本,但这个问题在政策上很少受到关注。我们建议医疗保健提供者让卫生系统规划者参与系统层面、对政策敏感的过渡策略的设计和评估。