Krol Marieke, Papenburg Jocé, Tan Siok Swan, Brouwer Werner, Hakkaart Leona
Department of Health Policy and Management, Erasmus University, P.O. Box 1738, 3000, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Institute for Medical Technology Assessment, Erasmus University, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Eur J Health Econ. 2016 May;17(4):391-402. doi: 10.1007/s10198-015-0685-x. Epub 2015 Apr 16.
Productivity costs can strongly impact cost-effectiveness outcomes. This study investigated the impact in the context of expensive hospital drugs. This study aimed to: (1) investigate the effect of productivity costs on cost-effectiveness outcomes, (2) determine whether economic evaluations of expensive drugs commonly include productivity costs related to paid and unpaid work, and (3) explore potential reasons for excluding productivity costs from the economic evaluation. We conducted a systematic literature review to identify economic evaluations of 33 expensive drugs. We analysed whether evaluations included productivity costs and whether inclusion or exclusion was related to the study population's age, health and national health economic guidelines. The impact on cost-effectiveness outcomes was assessed in studies that included productivity costs. Of 249 identified economic evaluations of expensive drugs, 22 (9 %) included productivity costs related to paid work. One study included unpaid productivity. Mostly, productivity cost exclusion could not be explained by the study population's age and health status, but national guidelines appeared influential. Productivity costs proved often highly influential. This study indicates that productivity costs in economic evaluations of expensive hospital drugs are commonly and inconsistently ignored in economic evaluations. This warrants caution in interpreting and comparing the results of these evaluations.
生产力成本会对成本效益结果产生重大影响。本研究在昂贵的医院药物背景下调查了这种影响。本研究旨在:(1)调查生产力成本对成本效益结果的影响;(2)确定昂贵药物的经济评估是否通常包括与有偿和无偿工作相关的生产力成本;(3)探究在经济评估中排除生产力成本的潜在原因。我们进行了一项系统的文献综述,以确定对33种昂贵药物的经济评估。我们分析了评估是否包括生产力成本,以及纳入或排除是否与研究人群的年龄、健康状况和国家卫生经济指南有关。在包括生产力成本的研究中评估了对成本效益结果的影响。在249项已确定的昂贵药物经济评估中,22项(9%)包括与有偿工作相关的生产力成本。一项研究包括无偿生产力成本。大多数情况下,生产力成本的排除无法用研究人群的年龄和健康状况来解释,但国家指南似乎具有影响力。生产力成本往往被证明具有高度影响力。本研究表明,在昂贵医院药物的经济评估中,生产力成本在经济评估中通常被忽视且不一致。这在解释和比较这些评估结果时需要谨慎。