Dedert Eric A, McDuffie Jennifer R, Stein Roy, McNiel J Murray, Kosinski Andrzej S, Freiermuth Caroline E, Hemminger Adam, Williams John W
Ann Intern Med. 2015 Aug 4;163(3):205-14. doi: 10.7326/M15-0285.
The use of electronic interventions (e-interventions) may improve treatment of alcohol misuse.
To characterize treatment intensity and systematically review the evidence for efficacy of e-interventions, relative to controls, for reducing alcohol consumption and alcohol-related impairment in adults and college students.
MEDLINE (via PubMed) from January 2000 to March 2015 and the Cochrane Library, EMBASE, and PsycINFO from January 2000 to August 2014.
English-language, randomized, controlled trials that involved at least 50 adults who misused alcohol; compared an e-intervention group with a control group; and reported outcomes at 6 months or longer.
Two reviewers abstracted data and independently rated trial quality and strength of evidence.
In 28 unique trials, the modal e-intervention was brief feedback on alcohol consumption. Available data suggested a small reduction in consumption (approximately 1 drink per week) in adults and college students at 6 months but not at 12 months. There was no statistically significant effect on meeting drinking limit guidelines in adults or on binge-drinking episodes or social consequences of alcohol in college students.
E-interventions that ranged in intensity were combined in analyses. Quantitative results do not apply to short-term outcomes or alcohol use disorders.
Evidence suggests that low-intensity e-inter ventions produce small reductions in alcohol consumption at 6 months, but there is little evidence for longer-term, clinically significant effects, such as meeting drinking limits. Future e-interventions could provide more intensive treatment and possibly human support to assist persons in meeting recommended drinking limits.
U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs.
使用电子干预措施可能会改善酒精滥用的治疗效果。
描述治疗强度,并系统评价相对于对照组,电子干预措施在减少成年人和大学生酒精摄入量及酒精相关损害方面的疗效证据。
2000年1月至2015年3月的MEDLINE(通过PubMed)以及2000年1月至2014年8月的Cochrane图书馆、EMBASE和PsycINFO。
涉及至少50名酒精滥用成年人的英文随机对照试验;将电子干预组与对照组进行比较;并报告6个月或更长时间的结果。
两名评审员提取数据并独立评定试验质量和证据强度。
在28项独特试验中,典型的电子干预措施是关于酒精摄入量的简短反馈。现有数据表明,成年人和大学生在6个月时酒精摄入量略有减少(约每周1杯),但在12个月时没有减少。对于成年人达到饮酒限量指南、大学生的暴饮事件或酒精的社会后果,没有统计学上的显著影响。
分析中合并了强度不同的电子干预措施。定量结果不适用于短期结果或酒精使用障碍。
证据表明,低强度电子干预措施在6个月时可使酒精摄入量略有减少,但几乎没有证据表明有长期的临床显著效果,如达到饮酒限量。未来的电子干预措施可以提供更强化的治疗,并可能提供人力支持,以帮助人们达到推荐的饮酒限量。
美国退伍军人事务部。