Perignon Marlène, Vieux Florent, Soler Louis-Georges, Masset Gabriel, Darmon Nicole
M. Perignon and G. Masset are with the UMR NORT (Unité Mixte de Recherche - Nutrition, Obesity and Risk of Thrombosis), Aix-Marseille Université, INSERM, INRA 1260, Marseille, France. F. Vieux is with MS-Nutrition, Marseille, France. L.-G. Soler is with the Unité de Recherche Aliss, INRA 1303, Ivry sur Seine, France. N. Darmon is with UMR MOISA (Markets, Organizations, Institutions and Stakeholders Strategies), INRA 1110, Montpellier, France.
Nutr Rev. 2017 Jan;75(1):2-17. doi: 10.1093/nutrit/nuw043.
The Food and Agriculture Organization defines sustainable diets as nutritionally adequate, safe, healthy, culturally acceptable, economically affordable diets that have little environmental impact. This review summarizes the studies assessing, at the individual level, both the environmental impact and the nutritional quality or healthiness of self-selected diets. Reductions in meat consumption and energy intake were identified as primary factors for reducing diet-related greenhouse gas emissions. The choice of foods to replace meat, however, was crucial, with some isocaloric substitutions possibly increasing total diet greenhouse gas emissions. Moreover, nutritional adequacy was rarely or only partially assessed, thereby compromising the assessment of diet sustainability. Furthermore, high nutritional quality was not necessarily associated with affordability or lower environmental impact. Hence, when identifying sustainable diets, each dimension needs to be assessed by relevant indicators. Finally, some nonvegetarian self-selected diets consumed by a substantial fraction of the population showed good compatibility with the nutritional, environmental, affordability, and acceptability dimensions. Altogether, the reviewed studies revealed the scarcity of standardized nationally representative data for food prices and environmental indicators and suggest that diet sustainability might be increased without drastic dietary changes.
联合国粮食及农业组织将可持续饮食定义为营养充足、安全、健康、在文化上可接受、经济上可承受且对环境影响较小的饮食。本综述总结了在个体层面评估自选饮食的环境影响以及营养质量或健康程度的研究。肉类消费和能量摄入的减少被确定为降低与饮食相关的温室气体排放的主要因素。然而,用来替代肉类的食物选择至关重要,一些等热量替代可能会增加整个饮食的温室气体排放。此外,营养充足性很少或只是部分得到评估,从而影响了对饮食可持续性的评估。此外,高营养质量不一定与可承受性或较低的环境影响相关联。因此,在确定可持续饮食时,每个维度都需要通过相关指标进行评估。最后,相当一部分人口所食用的一些非素食自选饮食在营养、环境、可承受性和可接受性维度上表现出良好的兼容性。总体而言,所综述的研究揭示了食品价格和环境指标方面标准化国家代表性数据的匮乏,并表明在不进行剧烈饮食改变的情况下也可能提高饮食可持续性。