Pettit Robin K, McCoy Lise, Kinney Marjorie
School of Osteopathic Medicine in Arizona, A. T. Still University, Mesa, AZ, USA.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2017 Jul 20;8:487-497. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S139569. eCollection 2017.
Flipped instruction is gaining popularity in medical schools, but there are unanswered questions such as the optimum amount of the curriculum to flip and whether flipped sessions should be mandatory. We were in a unique position to evaluate feedback from first-year medical students who had experienced both flipped and lecture-based courses during their first semester of medical school. A key finding was that the students preferred a variety of different learning formats over an "all or nothing" learning format. Learning format preferences did not necessarily align with perceptions of which format led to better course exam performance. Nearly 70% of respondents wanted to make their own decisions regarding attendance. Candid responses to open-ended survey prompts reflected millennial preferences for choice, flexibility, efficiency, and the ability to control the pace of their learning, providing insight to guide curricular improvements.
翻转课堂教学法在医学院校越来越受欢迎,但仍存在一些未解决的问题,比如课程的最佳翻转量以及翻转课程是否应该强制要求。我们处于一个独特的位置,可以评估一年级医学生的反馈,这些学生在医学院的第一学期既体验过翻转课堂教学法,也体验过传统讲座式课程。一个关键发现是,学生们更喜欢多种不同的学习形式,而不是“非此即彼”的学习形式。学习形式偏好不一定与哪种形式能带来更好的课程考试成绩的看法一致。近70%的受访者希望自行决定是否参加课程。对开放式调查问题的坦率回答反映了千禧一代对选择、灵活性、效率以及掌控自己学习节奏能力的偏好,为指导课程改进提供了见解。