Oberlin Lauren E, Waiwood Aashna M, Cumming Toby B, Marsland Anna L, Bernhardt Julie, Erickson Kirk I
From the Department of Psychology (L.E.O., A.M.W., A.L.M., K.I.E.), and Center for the Neural Basis of Cognition (L.E.O., K.I.E.), University of Pittsburgh, PA; and The Florey Institute of Neuroscience and Mental Health, University of Melbourne, Australia (T.B.C, J.B.).
Stroke. 2017 Nov;48(11):3093-3100. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.117.017319. Epub 2017 Sep 20.
Despite the social, health, and economic burdens associated with cognitive impairment poststroke, there is considerable uncertainty about the types of interventions that might preserve or restore cognitive abilities. The objective of this systematic review and meta-analysis was to evaluate the effects of physical activity (PA) training on cognitive function poststroke and identify intervention and sample characteristics that may moderate treatment effects.
Randomized controlled trials examining the association between structured PA training and cognitive performance poststroke were identified using electronic databases EMBASE and MEDLINE. Intervention effects were represented by Hedges' g and combined into pooled effect sizes using random- and mixed-effects models. Effect sizes were subjected to moderation analyses using the between-group heterogeneity test.
Fourteen studies met inclusion criteria, representing data from 736 participants. The primary analysis yielded a positive overall effect of PA training on cognitive performance (Hedges' g [95% confidence interval]=0.304 [0.14-0.47]). Mixed-effects analyses demonstrated that combined aerobic and strength training programs generated the largest cognitive gains and that improvements in cognitive performance were achieved even in the chronic stroke phase (mean=2.6 years poststroke). Positive moderate treatment effects were found for attention/processing speed measures (Hedges' g [confidence interval]=0.37 [0.10-0.63]), while the executive function and working memory domains did not reach significance (>0.05).
We found a significant positive effect of PA training on cognition poststroke with small to moderate treatment effects that are apparent even in the chronic stroke phase. Our findings support the use of PA training as a treatment strategy to promote cognitive recovery in stroke survivors.
尽管卒中后认知障碍会带来社会、健康和经济负担,但对于可能保留或恢复认知能力的干预类型仍存在很大不确定性。本系统评价和荟萃分析的目的是评估体力活动(PA)训练对卒中后认知功能的影响,并确定可能调节治疗效果的干预措施和样本特征。
使用电子数据库EMBASE和MEDLINE检索了研究结构化PA训练与卒中后认知表现之间关联的随机对照试验。干预效果用Hedges' g表示,并使用随机效应模型和混合效应模型合并为汇总效应量。使用组间异质性检验对效应量进行调节分析。
14项研究符合纳入标准,代表了736名参与者的数据。初步分析得出PA训练对认知表现有积极的总体影响(Hedges' g [95%置信区间]=0.304 [0.14 - 0.47])。混合效应分析表明,有氧训练和力量训练相结合的项目产生的认知改善最大,即使在卒中慢性期(卒中后平均2.6年)也能实现认知表现的改善。在注意力/处理速度测量方面发现了积极的中度治疗效果(Hedges' g [置信区间]=0.37 [0.10 - 0.63]),而执行功能和工作记忆领域未达到显著水平(>0.05)。
我们发现PA训练对卒中后认知有显著的积极影响,治疗效果小到中度,即使在卒中慢性期也很明显。我们的研究结果支持将PA训练作为一种治疗策略,以促进卒中幸存者的认知恢复。