Ye Chengyin, Wang Oliver, Liu Modi, Zheng Le, Xia Minjie, Hao Shiying, Jin Bo, Jin Hua, Zhu Chunqing, Huang Chao Jung, Gao Peng, Ellrodt Gray, Brennan Denny, Stearns Frank, Sylvester Karl G, Widen Eric, McElhinney Doff B, Ling Xuefeng
Department of Health Management, Hangzhou Normal University, Hangzhou, China.
HBI Solutions Inc, Palo Alto, CA, United States.
J Med Internet Res. 2019 Jul 5;21(7):e13719. doi: 10.2196/13719.
The rapid deterioration observed in the condition of some hospitalized patients can be attributed to either disease progression or imperfect triage and level of care assignment after their admission. An early warning system (EWS) to identify patients at high risk of subsequent intrahospital death can be an effective tool for ensuring patient safety and quality of care and reducing avoidable harm and costs.
The aim of this study was to prospectively validate a real-time EWS designed to predict patients at high risk of inpatient mortality during their hospital episodes.
Data were collected from the system-wide electronic medical record (EMR) of two acute Berkshire Health System hospitals, comprising 54,246 inpatient admissions from January 1, 2015, to September 30, 2017, of which 2.30% (1248/54,246) resulted in intrahospital deaths. Multiple machine learning methods (linear and nonlinear) were explored and compared. The tree-based random forest method was selected to develop the predictive application for the intrahospital mortality assessment. After constructing the model, we prospectively validated the algorithms as a real-time inpatient EWS for mortality.
The EWS algorithm scored patients' daily and long-term risk of inpatient mortality probability after admission and stratified them into distinct risk groups. In the prospective validation, the EWS prospectively attained a c-statistic of 0.884, where 99 encounters were captured in the highest risk group, 69% (68/99) of whom died during the episodes. It accurately predicted the possibility of death for the top 13.3% (34/255) of the patients at least 40.8 hours before death. Important clinical utilization features, together with coded diagnoses, vital signs, and laboratory test results were recognized as impactful predictors in the final EWS.
In this study, we prospectively demonstrated the capability of the newly-designed EWS to monitor and alert clinicians about patients at high risk of in-hospital death in real time, thereby providing opportunities for timely interventions. This real-time EWS is able to assist clinical decision making and enable more actionable and effective individualized care for patients' better health outcomes in target medical facilities.
部分住院患者病情迅速恶化,这可能归因于疾病进展,也可能是入院后分诊不完善及护理级别分配不当。早期预警系统(EWS)可识别有院内死亡高风险的患者,是确保患者安全和护理质量、减少可避免伤害及成本的有效工具。
本研究旨在前瞻性验证一种实时EWS,该系统旨在预测住院期间有院内死亡高风险的患者。
从伯克希尔医疗系统两家急症医院的全系统电子病历(EMR)中收集数据,涵盖2015年1月1日至2017年9月30日期间的54246例住院患者,其中2.30%(1248/54246)患者在院内死亡。探索并比较了多种机器学习方法(线性和非线性)。选择基于树的随机森林方法来开发用于院内死亡率评估的预测应用程序。构建模型后,我们前瞻性地验证了该算法作为实时住院患者死亡率EWS的有效性。
EWS算法对患者入院后的每日及长期院内死亡概率风险进行评分,并将其分为不同风险组。在前瞻性验证中,EWS前瞻性地获得了0.884的c统计量,其中99例患者被归入最高风险组,其中69%(68/99)在住院期间死亡。它在患者死亡前至少40.8小时准确预测了前13.3%(34/255)患者的死亡可能性。重要的临床应用特征,连同编码诊断、生命体征和实验室检查结果,被确认为最终EWS中有影响力的预测因素。
在本研究中,我们前瞻性地证明了新设计的EWS能够实时监测并提醒临床医生注意有院内死亡高风险的患者,从而提供及时干预的机会。这种实时EWS能够协助临床决策,为目标医疗设施中的患者提供更具可操作性和有效性的个性化护理,以实现更好的健康结局。