The Mind Research Network, Albuquerque, NM, USA.
The Mind Research Network, Albuquerque, NM, USA.
Schizophr Res. 2020 Jan;215:229-240. doi: 10.1016/j.schres.2019.10.023. Epub 2019 Nov 6.
Despite increased reporting of resting-state magnetoencephalography (MEG), reliability of those measures remains scarce and predominately reported in healthy controls (HC). As such, there is limited knowledge on MEG resting-state reliability in schizophrenia (SZ).
To address test-retest reliability in psychosis, a reproducibility study of 26 participants (13-SZ, 13-HC) was performed. We collected eyes open and eyes closed resting-state data during 4 separate instances (2 Visits, 2 runs per visit) to estimate spectral power reliability (power, normalized power, alpha reactivity) across one hour and one week. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) were calculated. For source modeling, we applied an anatomically constrained linear estimation inverse model known as dynamic statistical parametric mapping (MNE dSPM) and source-based connectivity using the weighted phase lag index.
Across one week there was excellent test-retest reliability in global spectral measures in theta-gamma bands (HC ICC = 0.87, SZ ICC = 0.87), regional spectral measures in all bands (HC ICC = 0.86, SZ ICC = 0.80), and parietal alpha measures (HC ICC = 0.90, SZ ICC = 0.84). Conversely, functional connectivity had poor reliability, as did source spectral power across one hour for SZ. Relative to HC, SZ also had reduced parietal alpha normalized power during eyes closed only, reduced alpha reactivity, and an association between higher PANSS positive scores and lower parietal alpha power.
There was excellent to good test-retest reliability in most MEG spectral measures with a few exceptions in the schizophrenia patient group. Overall, these findings encourage the use of resting-state MEG while emphasizing the importance of determining reliability in clinical populations.
尽管静息态脑磁图(MEG)的报告越来越多,但这些测量的可靠性仍然很少,并且主要在健康对照组(HC)中报告。因此,关于精神分裂症(SZ)中 MEG 静息态可靠性的知识有限。
为了在精神病中解决测试-重测可靠性,对 26 名参与者(13 名 SZ,13 名 HC)进行了可重复性研究。我们在 4 个不同的实例(2 次就诊,每次就诊 2 次运行)中采集了睁眼和闭眼静息状态数据,以在 1 小时和 1 周内估计频谱功率可靠性(功率、归一化功率、alpha 反应性)。计算了组内相关系数(ICC)。对于源建模,我们应用了一种称为动态统计参数映射(MNE dSPM)的解剖约束线性估计逆模型和基于源的连通性,使用加权相位滞后指数。
在一周内,θ-γ 波段的全局频谱测量(HC ICC=0.87,SZ ICC=0.87)、所有波段的区域频谱测量(HC ICC=0.86,SZ ICC=0.80)和顶叶α 测量(HC ICC=0.90,SZ ICC=0.84)具有极好的测试-重测可靠性。相反,功能连接的可靠性较差,SZ 在 1 小时内的源频谱功率也较差。与 HC 相比,SZ 在闭眼时仅表现出顶叶α 归一化功率降低、α 反应性降低,以及 PANSS 阳性评分较高与顶叶α 功率降低之间存在关联。
在大多数 MEG 频谱测量中,除了在精神分裂症患者组中存在一些例外,测试-重测可靠性都很好。总体而言,这些发现鼓励在临床人群中使用静息态 MEG,同时强调确定可靠性的重要性。