Argent Sarah Elizabeth, Kalebic Natasha, Rice Frances, Taylor Pamela
Division of Psychological Medicine and Clinical Neurosciences, Cardiff University School of Medicine, Cardiff, UK
Division of Psychological Medicine and Clinical Neurosciences, Cardiff University School of Medicine, Cardiff, UK.
Evid Based Ment Health. 2020 Aug;23(3):113-121. doi: 10.1136/ebmental-2019-300123. Epub 2020 Apr 17.
We sought evidence on quantifiable offspring outcomes, including problems, needs and strengths, associated with their experience of major parental psychiatric disorder(s), focusing on schizophrenia, affective illnesses and personality disorder(s). We were motivated by the absence of any systematic exploration of the needs of offspring of parents in secure hospitals. Seven electronic databases were searched to identify systematic reviews of studies quantifying offspring outcomes when a parent, or parent surrogate, has major psychiatric disorder(s). Our search (updated in February 2018) identified seven high-quality reviews, which incorporated 291 unique papers, published in 1974-2017. The weight of evidence is of increased risk of poor offspring outcomes, including psychiatric disorder and/or behavioural, emotional, cognitive or social difficulties. No review explored child strengths. Potential moderators and mediators examined included aspects of parental disorder (eg, severity), parent and child gender and age, parenting behaviours, and family functioning. This clinical review is the first review of systematic reviews to focus on quantifiable offspring problems, needs or strengths when a parent has major psychiatric disorder(s). It narratively synthesises findings, emphasising the increased risk of offspring problems, while highlighting limits to what is known, especially the extent to which any increased risk of childhood problems endures and the extent to which aspects of parental disorder moderate offspring outcomes. The absence of the reviews' consideration of child strengths and protective factors limits opportunity to enhance offspring resilience.
我们探寻了与父母患有严重精神疾病(主要关注精神分裂症、情感性疾病和人格障碍)的子女经历相关的可量化的子女结局的证据,包括问题、需求和优势。我们的动机源于安全医院中对父母患有精神疾病的子女需求缺乏任何系统性探索。检索了七个电子数据库,以确定对父母或父母替代者患有严重精神疾病时量化子女结局的研究进行的系统评价。我们的检索(于2018年2月更新)确定了七项高质量评价,这些评价纳入了1974年至2017年发表的291篇独立论文。证据表明,子女出现不良结局(包括精神疾病和/或行为、情感、认知或社交困难)的风险增加。没有评价探讨儿童的优势。所考察的潜在调节因素和中介因素包括父母疾病的各个方面(如严重程度)、父母和子女的性别及年龄、养育行为以及家庭功能。这项临床评价是首次对系统评价进行的综述,重点关注父母患有严重精神疾病时可量化的子女问题、需求或优势。它对研究结果进行了叙述性综合,强调了子女出现问题的风险增加,同时突出了已知内容的局限性,特别是儿童问题增加的风险持续存在的程度以及父母疾病的各个方面对子女结局产生调节作用的程度。评价未考虑儿童优势和保护因素,这限制了增强子女复原力的机会。