Pounder R E, Hunt R H, Vincent S H, Milton-Thompson G J, Misiewicz J J
Gut. 1977 Feb;18(2):85-90. doi: 10.1136/gut.18.2.85.
Cimetidine markedly inhibits gastric acid secretion, but from the therapeutic point of view it is important to know whether concurrent treatment with an anticholinergic increases its effect. This possibility has been investigated by measuring the 24 h intragastric acidity and nocturnal output of acid in four duodenal ulcer patients, each receiving on separate occasions cimetidine 1 g/day and placebo, atropine 2-4 mg/day and placebo, cimetidine and atropine, or two placebos. Cimetidine alone decreased mean hourly hydrogen ion activity by 63% of control values, decreased mean hourly hydrogen ion concentration (total acid) by 41%, inhibited nocturnal acid secretion by 83% and resulted in half the nocturnal samples being anacidic. Atropine alone had no effect when compared with control and combined treatment with both drugs was not superior to cimetidine alone. Atropine did not affect the absorption or urinary excretion of cimetidine. Fasting serum gastrin concentrations were not changed by any of the treatments. At the doses studied, the combination of cimetidine with an anticholinergic appears to offer no advantages over treatment with the H2-antagonist alone. Cimetidine is the only potent anti-secretory drug that does not cause acute side-effects and this important advantage would be lost if it were given with a maximal dose of an anticholinergic.
西咪替丁能显著抑制胃酸分泌,但从治疗角度来看,了解与抗胆碱能药物联合使用是否会增强其效果很重要。通过测量4名十二指肠溃疡患者的24小时胃内酸度和夜间胃酸分泌量,对这种可能性进行了研究。这4名患者在不同时间分别接受了以下治疗:每天1克西咪替丁和安慰剂、每天2 - 4毫克阿托品和安慰剂、西咪替丁与阿托品联合使用,或两种安慰剂。单独使用西咪替丁可使平均每小时氢离子活性降低至对照值的63%,使平均每小时氢离子浓度(总酸)降低41%,抑制夜间胃酸分泌83%,并使夜间样本中有一半呈无酸状态。与对照相比,单独使用阿托品没有效果,两种药物联合治疗并不优于单独使用西咪替丁。阿托品不影响西咪替丁的吸收或尿排泄。任何一种治疗都不会改变空腹血清胃泌素浓度。在所研究的剂量下,西咪替丁与抗胆碱能药物联合使用似乎并不比单独使用H2拮抗剂治疗更具优势。西咪替丁是唯一一种不会引起急性副作用的强效抗分泌药物,如果与最大剂量的抗胆碱能药物合用,这一重要优势将会丧失。