Bub Daniel N, Masson Michael E J, van Noordenne Maria
Department of Psychology, University of Victoria.
J Exp Psychol Hum Percept Perform. 2021 Jan;47(1):53-80. doi: 10.1037/xhp0000876. Epub 2020 Sep 24.
In an extension of Gibson's (1979) concept of object affordance, it has been proposed that motor representations are automatically evoked by pictures of graspable objects. A variety of effects on left/right-handed keypress responses to the perceptual attributes of such images have been taken as evidence that features of actions, including the hand best suited to grasp an object, contribute to the effect of the handle's left/right location on response selection. We present an argument against this claim by establishing that all of these effects are based on spatial codes, including effects mistakenly interpreted to reflect the influence of limb-specific features of a grasp action. We also present 6 experiments showing that under certain task conditions, limb-specific effects on response selection are indeed automatically generated by the task-irrelevant image of a graspable object. These effects are found either when the observer makes keypress or reach-and-grasp responses to the laterality of a pictured hand superimposed on a depicted object. Both tasks recruit control processes that determine how the hand is selected and configured to grasp an object. We infer that processes implicated in the planning of a reach-and-grasp action themselves determine whether the task-irrelevant picture of an object triggers motor-based rather than spatial features. Our results have deep implications for the widely used concept of an affordance for action furnished by an object. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2020 APA, all rights reserved).
在对吉布森(1979年)的物体可供性概念的拓展中,有人提出可抓握物体的图片会自动唤起运动表征。对这类图像的感知属性进行左右按键反应的各种影响,被视为一种证据,表明动作特征,包括最适合抓握物体的手,会影响把手的左右位置对反应选择的作用。我们通过证明所有这些影响都基于空间编码,包括那些被错误解释为反映抓握动作特定肢体特征影响的效应,来反驳这一观点。我们还展示了6个实验,表明在某些任务条件下,可抓握物体的与任务无关的图像确实会自动产生对反应选择的特定肢体效应。当观察者对叠加在描绘物体上的图片手部的左右位置进行按键或伸手抓握反应时,都会发现这些效应。这两项任务都需要控制过程来确定如何选择和配置手部以抓握物体。我们推断,涉及伸手抓握动作规划的过程本身决定了与任务无关的物体图片是触发基于运动的特征还是空间特征。我们的结果对广泛使用的物体提供动作可供性的概念具有深远影响。(PsycInfo数据库记录(c)2020美国心理学会,保留所有权利)