School of Communication, The Ohio State University College of Arts and Sciences, Columbus.
Department of Psychology, The Ohio State University College of Arts and Sciences, Columbus.
JAMA Netw Open. 2020 Dec 1;3(12):e2029571. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.29571.
Despite broad public support for gun safety policies, minimal policy implementation has occurred.
To investigate factors that encourage greater private support for and public action on gun safety policy.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: Three studies were conducted: a public opinion survey (Study 1) was conducted from January 8 to 22, 2019, and 2 experiments (Studies 2 and 3) were conducted from August 27 to October 17, 2019, and April 15 to 21, 2020, respectively. Adults living in the US were eligible to participate in Studies 1 and 3. Students 18 years and older participating in a research experience program were eligible to participate in Study 2. Study 1 was administered online by Ipsos, a market research company. A nationally representative sample of 1000 US adults was obtained from Ipsos' online KnowledgePanel, of whom 508 completed the public opinion survey. For Study 2, which was conducted in a university laboratory, 354 participants were recruited from a university research pool, all of whom completed the study. Study 3 was administered online by the market research company YouGov, which identified 727 US gun owners from its opt-in panel, from which it constructed a census-matched sample of 400 participants.
Participants read a statement about the 2018 Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School shooting. Content was manipulated as a 2 (corrective information vs no corrective information) × 2 (system changeable vs system not changeable) between-subjects factorial design with random assignment. The corrective information included polling data highlighting widespread support among gun owners for several gun safety policies. System changeable described gun safety policies passed by Florida's legislature.
Main outcomes were support for gun safety policies and public disclosure of support.
The 3 studies included a total of 1262 participants (Study 1: 508 participants; weighted mean [SD] age, 47.7 [17.5] years; 261.9 women [51.6%]; 82.5 Hispanic [16.2%] and 60.3 Black [11.9%]; Study 2: 354 participants; mean [SD] age, 20.0 [2.3] years; 232 women [65.9%]; 100 Asian [28.3%] and 37 Black [10.5%]; Study 3: 400 participants; weighted mean [SD] age, 52.1 [16.4] years; 187.3 women [46.8%]; 295.5 White [73.9%], 44.5 Hispanic [11.1%], and 32.4 Black [8.1%]). Study 1 found that 63% to 91% of gun owners and 83% to 93% of non-gun owners supported key gun safety policies, yet both groups significantly underestimated gun owners' support for these policies by between 12% and 31%. Studies 2 and 3 found that exposure to corrective information was associated with a small increase in support for 2 gun safety policies of between 4% and 15%, both in terms of participants' privately held beliefs and the beliefs they would be willing to share publicly.
This survey study found that many US adults failed to recognize that most gun owners support key gun safety policies. Correcting this misperception was associated with greater private and public support for gun safety policy.
尽管公众普遍支持枪支安全政策,但实施的政策很少。
调查鼓励更多的私人支持和公众采取枪支安全政策的因素。
设计、设置和参与者:进行了三项研究:一项公众意见调查(研究 1)于 2019 年 1 月 8 日至 22 日进行,两项实验(研究 2 和 3)分别于 2019 年 8 月 27 日至 10 月 17 日和 2020 年 4 月 15 日至 21 日进行。居住在美国的成年人有资格参加研究 1 和 3。参加研究经验计划的 18 岁及以上的学生有资格参加研究 2。研究 1 由市场研究公司益普索在线进行。从 Ipsos 的在线知识面板中获得了 1000 名美国成年人的全国代表性样本,其中 508 人完成了公众意见调查。在大学实验室进行的研究 2 中,从大学研究池中招募了 354 名参与者,他们都完成了研究。研究 3 由市场研究公司 YouGov 在线进行,该公司从其选择加入的小组中确定了 727 名美国枪支拥有者,并根据该小组构建了一个人口匹配的 400 名参与者样本。
参与者阅读了一篇关于 2018 年玛乔丽·斯通曼·道格拉斯高中枪击案的声明。内容以 2(纠正信息与无纠正信息)×2(系统可更改与系统不可更改)的随机分配组间因子设计进行操纵。纠正信息包括民意调查数据,突出显示枪支拥有者对几项枪支安全政策的广泛支持。系统可更改性描述了佛罗里达州立法机构通过的枪支安全政策。
主要结果是对枪支安全政策的支持和公开支持的披露。
这三项研究共包括 1262 名参与者(研究 1:508 名参与者;加权平均[SD]年龄,47.7[17.5]岁;261.9 名女性[51.6%];82.5 名西班牙裔[16.2%]和 60.3 名黑人[11.9%];研究 2:354 名参与者;平均[SD]年龄,20.0[2.3]岁;232 名女性[65.9%];100 名亚裔[28.3%]和 37 名黑人[10.5%];研究 3:400 名参与者;加权平均[SD]年龄,52.1[16.4]岁;187.3 名女性[46.8%];295.5 名白人[73.9%]、44.5 名西班牙裔[11.1%]和 32.4 名黑人[8.1%])。研究 1 发现,63%至 91%的枪支拥有者和 83%至 93%的非枪支拥有者支持关键的枪支安全政策,但这两个群体对这些政策的支持率都明显低估了 12%至 31%。研究 2 和 3 发现,接触纠正信息与对两项枪支安全政策的支持略有增加有关,增加幅度在 4%至 15%之间,无论是参与者私下持有的信念还是他们愿意公开分享的信念。
这项调查研究发现,许多美国成年人没有意识到大多数枪支拥有者支持关键的枪支安全政策。纠正这种误解与对枪支安全政策的更大的私人和公众支持有关。