Department of Epidemiology and Health Statistics, Fudan University, China.
Department of Biostatistics, Erasmus University Medical Center, the Netherlands.
Environ Res. 2021 Jul;198:111182. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2021.111182. Epub 2021 Apr 16.
Whether meteorological factors influence COVID-19 transmission is an issue of major public health concern, but available evidence remains unclear and limited for several reasons, including the use of report date which can lag date of symptom onset by a considerable period. We aimed to generate reliable and robust evidence of this relationship based on date of onset of symptoms. We evaluated important meteorological factors associated with daily COVID-19 counts and effective reproduction number (R) in China using a two-stage approach with overdispersed generalized additive models and random-effects meta-analysis. Spatial heterogeneity and stratified analyses by sex and age groups were quantified and potential effect modification was analyzed. Nationwide, there was no evidence that temperature and relative humidity affected COVID-19 incidence and R. However, there were heterogeneous impacts on COVID-19 risk across different regions. Importantly, there was a negative association between relative humidity and COVID-19 incidence in Central China: a 1% increase in relative humidity was associated with a 3.92% (95% CI, 1.98%-5.82%) decrease in daily counts. Older population appeared to be more sensitive to meteorological conditions, but there was no obvious difference between sexes. Linear relationships were found between meteorological variables and COVID-19 incidence. Sensitivity analysis confirmed the robustness of the association and the results based on report date were biased. Meteorological factors play heterogenous roles on COVID-19 transmission, increasing the possibility of seasonality and suggesting the epidemic is far from over. Considering potential climatic associations, we should maintain, not ease, current control measures and surveillance.
气象因素是否会影响 COVID-19 的传播是一个重大的公共卫生问题,但由于多种原因,包括使用可能会滞后于症状出现日期的报告日期,可用证据仍然不清楚且有限。我们旨在根据症状出现日期生成关于这种关系的可靠和稳健的证据。我们使用过离散广义加性模型和随机效应荟萃分析的两阶段方法评估了与中国每日 COVID-19 病例数和有效繁殖数(R)相关的重要气象因素。我们量化了空间异质性和按性别和年龄组分层的分析,并分析了潜在的效应修饰。在全国范围内,没有证据表明温度和相对湿度会影响 COVID-19 的发病率和 R。然而,不同地区的 COVID-19 风险存在异质性影响。重要的是,在中国中部地区,相对湿度与 COVID-19 发病率之间存在负相关:相对湿度每增加 1%,每日病例数就会减少 3.92%(95%CI,1.98%-5.82%)。老年人口似乎对气象条件更为敏感,但男女之间没有明显差异。气象变量与 COVID-19 发病率之间存在线性关系。敏感性分析证实了这种关联的稳健性,并且基于报告日期的结果存在偏差。气象因素对 COVID-19 的传播起着不同的作用,增加了季节性的可能性,并表明疫情远未结束。考虑到潜在的气候关联,我们应该保持而不是放松当前的控制措施和监测。