Departamento de Tecnología Electrónica, Universidad de Málaga, 29071 Málaga, Spain.
Departamento de Tecnología Electrónica, Universidad de Málaga, Instituto TELMA, 29071 Málaga, Spain.
Biosensors (Basel). 2021 Aug 19;11(8):284. doi: 10.3390/bios11080284.
In recent years, the popularity of wearable devices has fostered the investigation of automatic fall detection systems based on the analysis of the signals captured by transportable inertial sensors. Due to the complexity and variety of human movements, the detection algorithms that offer the best performance when discriminating falls from conventional Activities of Daily Living (ADLs) are those built on machine learning and deep learning mechanisms. In this regard, supervised machine learning binary classification methods have been massively employed by the related literature. However, the learning phase of these algorithms requires mobility patterns caused by falls, which are very difficult to obtain in realistic application scenarios. An interesting alternative is offered by One-Class Classifiers (OCCs), which can be exclusively trained and configured with movement traces of a single type (ADLs). In this paper, a systematic study of the performance of various typical OCCs (for diverse sets of input features and hyperparameters) is performed when applied to nine public repositories of falls and ADLs. The results show the potentials of these classifiers, which are capable of achieving performance metrics very similar to those of supervised algorithms (with values for the specificity and the sensitivity higher than 95%). However, the study warns of the need to have a wide variety of types of ADLs when training OCCs, since activities with a high degree of mobility can significantly increase the frequency of false alarms (ADLs identified as falls) if not considered in the data subsets used for training.
近年来,可穿戴设备的普及促进了基于可移动惯性传感器捕获的信号分析的自动跌倒检测系统的研究。由于人类运动的复杂性和多样性,在区分跌倒和日常活动(ADL)时表现出最佳性能的检测算法是基于机器学习和深度学习机制构建的。在这方面,相关文献大量采用了有监督的机器学习二进制分类方法。然而,这些算法的学习阶段需要由跌倒引起的移动模式,而在现实应用场景中很难获得这些模式。一类分类器(OCC)提供了一个有趣的替代方案,它可以仅使用单一类型(ADL)的运动轨迹进行专门的训练和配置。在本文中,针对九种公共跌倒和 ADL 存储库,对各种典型 OCC(针对不同的输入特征和超参数集)的性能进行了系统研究。结果表明了这些分类器的潜力,它们能够实现与有监督算法非常相似的性能指标(特异性和敏感性值高于 95%)。然而,该研究警告说,在训练 OCC 时需要有各种各样的 ADL 类型,因为如果不在用于训练的数据集子集中考虑到高度移动性的活动,则可能会显著增加误报的频率(将 ADL 识别为跌倒)。