Person-Centred Care, Ontario Health (Cancer Care Ontario), Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, ON M4N 3M5, Canada.
Program in Evidence-Based Care, Ontario Health (Cancer Care Ontario), Department of Oncology, McMaster University, Hamilton, ON L8S 4L8, Canada.
Curr Oncol. 2021 Sep 8;28(5):3488-3506. doi: 10.3390/curroncol28050301.
Virtual care in cancer care existed in a limited fashion globally before the COVID-19 pandemic, mostly driven by geographic constraints. The pandemic has required dramatic shifts in health care delivery, including cancer care. We conducted a systematic review of comparative studies evaluating virtual versus in-person care in patients with cancer. Embase, APA PsycInfo, Ovid MEDLINE, and the Cochrane Library were searched for literature from January 2015 to 6 August 2020. We adhered to PRISMA guidelines and used the modified GRADE approach to evaluate the data. We included 34 full-text publications of 10 randomized controlled trials, 13 non-randomized comparative studies, and 5 ongoing randomized controlled trials. Evidence was divided into studies that provide psychosocial or genetic counselling and those that provide or assess medical and supportive care. The limited data in this review support that in the general field of psychological counselling, virtual or remote counselling can be equivalent to in-person counselling. In the area of genetic counselling, telephone counselling was more convenient and noninferior to usual care for all outcomes (knowledge, decision conflict, cancer distress, perceived stress, genetic counseling satisfaction). There are few data for clinical outcomes and supportive care. Future research should assess the role of virtual care in these areas. Protocol registration: PROSPERO CRD42020202871.
在 COVID-19 大流行之前,虚拟医疗在癌症治疗中已经以有限的形式存在,主要是由于地理限制。大流行要求医疗服务(包括癌症护理)发生重大转变。我们对评估癌症患者虚拟护理与面对面护理的比较研究进行了系统评价。从 2015 年 1 月至 2020 年 8 月 6 日,我们在 Embase、APA PsycInfo、Ovid MEDLINE 和 Cochrane Library 中搜索文献。我们遵循 PRISMA 指南,并使用改良的 GRADE 方法评估数据。我们纳入了 10 项随机对照试验、13 项非随机对照研究和 5 项正在进行的随机对照试验的 34 篇全文出版物。证据分为提供心理社会或遗传咨询的研究和提供或评估医疗和支持性护理的研究。本综述中的有限数据支持在一般心理辅导领域,虚拟或远程辅导可以与面对面辅导相当。在遗传咨询领域,电话咨询在所有结果(知识、决策冲突、癌症困扰、感知压力、遗传咨询满意度)方面都更方便且不劣于常规护理。关于临床结果和支持性护理的数据很少。未来的研究应该评估虚拟护理在这些领域的作用。方案注册:PROSPERO CRD42020202871。