Youssef Layale, Granet Jordan, Marcangeli Vincent, Dulac Maude, Hajj-Boutros Guy, Reynaud Olivier, Buckinx Fanny, Gaudreau Pierrette, Morais José A, Mauriège Pascale, Gouspillou Gilles, Noirez Philippe, Aubertin-Leheudre Mylène
École de Kinésiologie et des Sciences de l'Activité Physique, Université de Montréal, Montreal, QC H3T 1J4, Canada.
Centre de Recherche de l'Institut, Universitaire de Gériatrie de Montréal, Montreal, QC H3W 1W5, Canada.
Healthcare (Basel). 2022 Jul 20;10(7):1346. doi: 10.3390/healthcare10071346.
Sarcopenia and obesity are considered a double health burden. Therefore, the implementation of effective strategies is needed to improve the quality of life of older obese individuals. The aim of this study was to compare the impact of high-intensity interval training (HIIT) and moderate-intensity continuous training (MICT) on functional capacities, muscle function, body composition and blood biomarkers in obese older adults. Adipose tissue gene expression and markers of muscle mitochondrial content and quality control involved in exercise adaptations were also investigated. Sixty-eight participants performed either HIIT ( = 34) on an elliptical trainer or MICT ( = 34) on a treadmill, three times per week for 12 weeks. HIIT produced significantly higher benefits on some physical parameters (six-minute walking test (HIIT: +12.4% vs. MICT: +5.2%); step test (HIIT: +17.02% vs. MICT: +5.9%); ten-repetition chair test (HIIT: -17.04% vs. MICT: -4.7%)). Although both HIIT and MICT led to an improvement in lower limb power (HIIT: +25.2% vs. MICT: +20.4%), only MICT led to higher improvement in lower limb muscle strength (HIIT: +4.3% vs. MICT: +23.2%). HIIT was more beneficial for increasing total lean body mass (HIIT: +1.58% vs. MICT: -0.81%), while MICT was more effective for decreasing relative gynoid fat mass (HIIT: -1.09% vs. MICT: -4.20%). Regarding adipose tissue gene expression, a significant change was observed for cell death-inducing DFFA (DNA fragmentation factor-alpha)-like effector A (CIDEA) in the HIIT group (A.U; HIIT at T0: 32.10 ± 39.37 vs. HIIT at T12: 48.2 ± 59.2). Mitochondrial transcription factor A (TFAM) content, a marker of mitochondrial biogenesis, increased significantly following HIIT (+36.2%) and MICT (+57.2%). A significant increase was observed in the HIIT group for Translocase of Outer Membrane 20 (TOM20; +54.1%; marker of mitochondrial content), Mitofusin-2 (MFN2; +71.6%; marker of mitochondrial fusion) and Parkin RBR E3 Ubiquitin Protein Ligase (PARKIN; +42.3%; marker of mitophagy). Overall, our results indicate that even though MICT (walking on treadmill) and HIIT (on an elliptical) are effective intervention strategies in obese older adults, HIIT appears to have slightly more beneficial effects. More specifically, HIIT led to higher improvements than MICT on functional capacities, lean mass and skeletal muscle markers of mitochondrial content, fusion, and mitophagy. Thus, MICT but also HIIT (time-efficient training) could be recommended as exercise modalities for obese older adults to maintain or improve mobility, health and quality of life.
肌肉减少症和肥胖被视为双重健康负担。因此,需要实施有效的策略来提高肥胖老年人的生活质量。本研究的目的是比较高强度间歇训练(HIIT)和中等强度持续训练(MICT)对肥胖老年人的功能能力、肌肉功能、身体成分和血液生物标志物的影响。还研究了脂肪组织基因表达以及参与运动适应的肌肉线粒体含量和质量控制的标志物。68名参与者在椭圆机上进行HIIT(n = 34)或在跑步机上进行MICT(n = 34),每周三次,共12周。HIIT在一些身体参数上产生了显著更高的益处(六分钟步行测试(HIIT:+12.4% 对 MICT:+5.2%);台阶测试(HIIT:+17.02% 对 MICT:+5.9%);十次重复椅子测试(HIIT:-17.04% 对 MICT:-4.7%))。虽然HIIT和MICT都导致下肢力量有所改善(HIIT:+25.2% 对 MICT:+20.4%),但只有MICT使下肢肌肉力量有更高的改善(HIIT:+4.3% 对 MICT:+23.2%)。HIIT在增加总体瘦体重方面更有益(HIIT:+1.58% 对 MICT:-0.81%),而MICT在降低相对臀部脂肪量方面更有效(HIIT:-1.09% 对 MICT:-4.20%)。关于脂肪组织基因表达,在HIIT组中观察到细胞死亡诱导DFFA(DNA片段化因子-α)样效应子A(CIDEA)有显著变化(A.U;HIIT在T0时:32.10 ± 39.37 对 HIIT在T12时:48.2 ± 59.2)。线粒体转录因子A(TFAM)含量,作为线粒体生物发生的标志物,在HIIT(+36.2%)和MICT(+57.2%)后显著增加。在HIIT组中观察到外膜转位酶20(TOM20;+54.1%;线粒体含量的标志物)、线粒体融合蛋白2(MFN2;+71.6%;线粒体融合的标志物)和帕金RBR E3泛素蛋白连接酶(PARKIN;+42.3%;线粒体自噬的标志物)有显著增加。总体而言,我们的结果表明,尽管MICT(在跑步机上行走)和HIIT(在椭圆机上)是肥胖老年人有效的干预策略,但HIIT似乎有稍多的有益效果。更具体地说,HIIT在功能能力、瘦体重以及线粒体含量、融合和自噬的骨骼肌标志物方面比MICT有更高的改善。因此,MICT以及HIIT(省时训练)都可被推荐为肥胖老年人维持或改善活动能力、健康和生活质量的运动方式。