Wu Yidong, Zhao Renjie, Zhang Yalin, Chen Zhuo
School of Business, Anhui University of Technology, Ma'anshan, China.
School of Economics and Management, Northwest University, Xi'an, China.
Front Psychol. 2022 Oct 20;13:1002647. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.1002647. eCollection 2022.
This article aims to answer the question that whether higher education would lead to happier life in China and tries to provide some explanations from the perspective of housing asset. Using data from four waves of China Household Finance Survey (CHFS), we find that higher education on average is significantly negatively correlated with people's happiness in urban China. Higher education tends to prevent people from achieving "extremely happy" lives; instead, it is more likely to lead to "acceptable" lives. Based on the realities of housing market in urban China, we find that housing asset plays the mediating role in the relationship between higher education and happiness. Specifically, years of schooling could evidently compress the years of being homeowners; as a result, highly educated people generally have more unpaid housing debts and bear more housing purchase costs due to the soaring housing prices. Meanwhile, higher education has negative effect on people's happiness in cities with relatively high housing prices, while this effect is insignificant in cities with relatively low housing prices. Moreover, the market-oriented housing reform that launched in 1998 has negative impact on highly educated people's happiness, since it has dramatically boosted housing prices and essentially changed housing distribution system for urban employees. Besides, we also find that Ph.D graduates are the relatively unhappiest people compared to bachelors or masters. Obviously, our findings have important policy implications for Chinese government to understand and resolve the "education-happiness paradox."
本文旨在回答高等教育是否会在中国带来更幸福生活这一问题,并试图从住房资产的角度提供一些解释。利用中国家庭金融调查(CHFS)四轮调查的数据,我们发现,在中国城市,高等教育平均而言与人们的幸福感显著负相关。高等教育往往会阻碍人们实现“极其幸福”的生活;相反,它更有可能带来“尚可接受”的生活。基于中国城市住房市场的现实情况,我们发现住房资产在高等教育与幸福之间的关系中起中介作用。具体而言,受教育年限会显著压缩拥有自有住房的年限;因此,由于房价飙升,高学历人群通常有更多的住房贷款未偿还,承担的购房成本也更高。同时,在房价相对较高的城市,高等教育对人们的幸福感有负面影响,而在房价相对较低的城市,这种影响不显著。此外,1998年启动的住房市场化改革对高学历人群的幸福感有负面影响,因为它大幅推高了房价,并从根本上改变了城市职工的住房分配制度。此外,我们还发现,与本科或硕士学历相比,博士毕业生是相对最不幸福的人群。显然,我们的研究结果对中国政府理解和解决“教育—幸福悖论”具有重要的政策意义。