Specific Didactics Department, Research Methods and Diagnosis in Education, University of A Coruña, 15001 A Coruña, Spain.
Faculty of Education, University of Camilo José Cela, 28692 Madrid, Spain.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2023 Jan 31;20(3):2586. doi: 10.3390/ijerph20032586.
In the last two decades, research has proliferated in the field of pedagogical models used in school Physical Education. The growth is so high that it is necessary to do a quick review to know which models currently exist and which are emerging. The objective of this work is to collect all the models or pedagogical approaches present in the scientific literature related to school Physical Education and to make known, to the scientific and academic community, its main purposes and characteristics. A quick review of the literature found in the Web of Science and Scopus databases has been carried out using "pedagogical model" and "Physical Education" as descriptors. The results revealed a total of 19 pedagogical approaches that record scientific evidence linked to their application in the classroom. It was detected that some models or approaches were more scientifically supported than others, as is the case for Cooperative Learning, Sports Education, or Teaching Games for Understanding, while others barely registered in international scientific literature. It was concluded that researchers need to work together with Physical Education teachers to analyze the effectiveness of all these approaches. School teachers are also encouraged to vary their pedagogical approach depending on the content they are working on and the positive effects they are looking for in the psychic, motor, affective-emotional, and social domains of the students. Finally, it is proposed to researchers who promote new models or approaches a greater clarity of these to facilitate their application in the field of school Physical Education, since some difficulty has been detected in the practical application of some approaches.
在过去的二十年中,学校体育教育中使用的教学模式的研究蓬勃发展。增长如此之高,有必要进行快速审查,以了解目前存在哪些模式以及哪些模式正在出现。这项工作的目的是收集与学校体育教育相关的科学文献中存在的所有模式或教学方法,并向科学界和学术界介绍其主要目的和特点。使用“教学模式”和“体育教育”作为描述符,对 Web of Science 和 Scopus 数据库中的文献进行了快速回顾。结果共发现了 19 种教学方法,这些方法记录了与在课堂上应用相关的科学证据。检测到一些模型或方法比其他方法更具有科学依据,例如合作学习、体育教育或理解教学游戏,而其他方法在国际科学文献中几乎没有记录。结论是,研究人员需要与体育教育教师合作,分析所有这些方法的有效性。学校教师也被鼓励根据他们正在处理的内容以及他们在学生的心理、运动、情感-情绪和社会领域中寻求的积极影响来改变他们的教学方法。最后,建议那些提出新模型或方法的研究人员更清楚地说明这些方法,以方便在学校体育教育领域的应用,因为在一些方法的实际应用中已经发现了一些困难。